Abstract
An engagement with affect theory is a significant way in which dimensions of social justice for the archival field can be elucidated, fleshed out, and ultimately confronted. Affect theory provides tools for undertaking substantive analyses of power and its abuses in order to better perform, more critically understand, and challenge and reconceptualize archival functions and concerns in support of social justice principles and goals. In this paper, I provide an introduction for the archival field to affect theory, arguing that the contributions of Ann Cvetkovich, Sara Ahmed and Lauren Berlant can critically expose, complicate and further work toward social justice in three areas of archival concern. First, drawing on Cvetkovich’s work, I argue that affective value should be surfaced and explicitly applied as an appraisal criterion. Second, extending Ahmed’s work on pain and witnessing to the archival realm and building on arguments that archivists are witnesses (Punzalan in Community archives: the shaping of memory, Facet, London, 187–219, 2009; Caswell in Archiving the unspeakable: Silence, memory and the photographic record in Cambodia. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, 2014a), I argue that archivists are deeply implicated in webs of affective relations. Such relations require the archival field to expand its ethical orientation to address considerations of emotional justice. Finally, I build out of Berlant’s work to call out, define and analyze a different kind of archival relation, an affective investment in and attachment to damaging neoliberalist ideologies that shape the conditions of contemporary archival work.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adam Matthew. (n.d.) Jewish life in America, c1654–1954. Sage. http://www.amdigital.co.uk/m-collections/collection/jewish-life-in-america-c1654-1954. Accessed 29 April 2015
Ahmed S (2004) The cultural politics of emotion. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh
Ahmed S (2006) Queer phenomenology: orientations, objects, others. Duke University Press, Durham
Ahmed S (2010) The promise of happiness. Duke University Press, Durham
Anderson K, Smith SJ (2001) Editorial: emotional geographies. Trans Inst Br Geogr 26:7–10
Archives Direct. Women in the National Archives. Adam Matthew http://www.archivesdirect.amdigital.co.uk/WTNA. Accessed 29 April 2015
Berlant L (1998) Intimacy: a special issue. Crit Inq 24(2):281–288
Berlant L (ed) (2004) Compassion: the culture and politics of an emotion. Routledge, London
Berlant L (2006) Cruel optimism. differ 17(1):20–36
Berlant L (2011) Cruel optimism. Duke University Press, Durham
Berlant L (2012) On her book cruel optimism. Rorotoko.com. 5 June http://rorotoko.com/interview/20120605_berlant_lauren_on_cruel_optimism/?page=4. Accessed 29 April 2015
Brennan T (2004) The transmission of affect. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Brothman B (1991) Orders of value: probing the theoretical terms of archival practice. Archivaria 32:78–100
Brown E, Phu T (2014) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham
Bulter J (2004) Precarious life: the powers of mourning and violence. Verso, London
Butler J (2009) Frames of war: when life is grievable. Verso, London
Canadian Council of Archives (2012) Memorandum on the elimination of the National Archival Development Program. http://www.cdncouncilarchives.ca/CCAFactSheet_v1.2Updated_EN.pdf. Accessed 9 Aug 2015
Caswell M (2014a) Archiving the unspeakable: silence, memory and the photographic record in Cambodia. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison
Caswell M (2014b) Towards a survivor-centered approach to records documenting human rights abuse: lessons from community archives. Arch Sci 14(3–4):307–322
Caswell M, Cifor M (2016) From human rights to feminist ethics: Radical empathy in the archives. Archivaria 81
Cifor M (2015) Presence, absence, and Victoria’s hair: affect and embodiment in trans archives. TSQ: Transgender Stud Q 2.2:645–649
Clough PT, Halley J (eds) (2007) The affective turn. Duke University Press, Durham
Cook T (2000) Archival science and postmodernism: New formulations for old concepts. Arch Sci 1:3–24
Cox R (2002) The end of collecting: towards a new purpose for archival appraisal. Arch Sci 2:287–309
Cvetkovich A (2002) In the archives of lesbian feelings: documentary and popular culture. Camera Obscura 49(1):107–147
Cvetkovich A (2003) An archive of feeling: trauma, sexuality and lesbian public cultures. Duke University Press, Durham
Cvetkovich A (2012) Depression: a public feeling. Duke University Press, Durham
Cvetkovich A (2014) Photographing objects as queer archival practice. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 273–296
Dever M (2010) Greta Garbo’s foot, or sex, socks, and letters. Aust Feminist Stud 25:163–173
Dever M, Newman S, Vickery A (2009) The intimate archive: Journeys through private papers. National Library of Australia, Canberra
Drabinski J (2014) Slavery, memory, property. 23 Jan. http://jdrabinski.com/slavery-memory-property. Accessed 15 April 2015
Duff WM, Flinn A, Suurtamm KE, Wallace DA (2013) Social justice impact of archives: a preliminary investigation. Arch Sci 13(4):317–348
Dunbar AW (2006) Introducing critical race theory to archival discourse: getting the conversation started. Arch Sci 6:109–129
Eichhorn K (2014) The archival turn in feminism: outrage in order. Temple University Press, Philadelphia
Ellis D, Tucker I, Harper D (2013) The affective atmospheres of surveillance. Theory Psychol 23(6):716–731
Eng D (2014) The feeling of photography, the feeling of kinship. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 325–348
Evans J, McKemmish S, Daniels E, McCarthy G (2015) Self-determination and archival autonomy: advocating activism. Arch Sci 1–32. doi:10.1007/s10502-015-9244-6
Farge A (2013) Allure of the archives. (T Scott-Railton, trans.). Yale University Press, New Haven
Flinn A (2011) Archival activism: independent and community-led archives, radical public history and the heritage professions. Inter Actions 7(2)
Freeman E (2010) Time binds: queer temporalities, queer histories. Duke University Press, Durham
Ghosh D (2006) National narratives and the politics of miscegenation: Britain and India. In: Burton A (ed) Archives stories: fact, fiction and the writing of history. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 27–44
Gilliland A (2011) Neutrality, social justice and the obligations of archival education and educators in the twenty-first century. Arch Sci 11(3–4):193–209
Gilliland AJ (2014a) Conceptualizing 21st-century archives. Society of American Archivists, Chicago
Gilliland AJ (2014b) Moving past: probing the agency and affect of recordkeeping in individual and community lives in post-conflict Croatia. Arch Sci 14:249–274
Gilliland AJ (2015) Studying affect and its relationship to the agency of archivists since the Yugoslav Wars. In: Cox RJ et al (eds) Studies in archival education and research: selected papers from the 2014 AERI conference. Litwin Press, Sacramento
Gilliland AJ, McKemmish S (2004) Building an infrastructure for archival research. Arch Sci 3(4):149–199
Gopinath G (2010) Archive, affect and the everyday: queer diasporic revisions. In: Staiger J, Cvetkovich A, Reynolds AM (eds) Political emotions. Routledge, New York, pp 165–192
Gorton K (2007) Theorizing emotion and affect: feminist engagements. Feminist Theory 8(3):333–348
Gregg M, Seigworth GJ (2010) An inventory of shimmers. In: Gregg M, Seigworth GJ (eds) The affect theory reader. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 1–28
Guerin F, Hallas R (2007) The image and the witness: trauma, memory and visual culture. Wallflower Press, London
Halilovich H (2014) Reclaiming erased lives: archives, records and memories in post-war Bosnia and the Bosnian diaspora. Arch Sci 14:231–247
Harding J, Pribram ED (2004) Losing our cool? Following Williams and Grossberg on emotions. Cult Studs 18(6):863–883
Harris V (2001) Seeing (in) blindness: South Africa, archives and passion for justice. http://scnc.ukzn.ac.za/doc/LibArchMus/Arch/Harris_V_Freedom_of_Information_in_SA_Archives_for_justice.pdf. Accessed 13 April 2015
Harris V (2002) The archival sliver: power, memory and archives in South Africa. Arch Sci 2(1–2):63–86
Harris V (2012) Genres of the trace. Arch Manus 40(3):147–157
Harris V (2014) Antonyms of our remembering. Arch Sci 14(3–4):215–229
Hartman S (2008) Lose your mother: a journey along the Atlantic slave trade route. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York
Harvey D (2007) Neoliberalism and creative destruction. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 610. NAFTA and beyond: Alternate perspectives in the study of global trade and development
Held V (2014) The Ethics of care as normative guidance: comment on Gilligan. J Soc Philos 45(1):107–115
Hirsch M, Spitzer L (2014) School photos and their afterlives. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 252–272
Holland S (2000) Raising the dead: readings of death and (black) subjectivity. Duke University Press, Durham
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) (1997) Bringing them home: report of the national inquiry into the separation of aboriginal and Torres strait islander children from their families. Australian Government Publishing Service, Sydney
Jimerson R (2007) Archives for all: professional responsibility and social justice. Am Arch 70(2):252–281
Jimerson R (2009) Archives power. Society of American Archivists, Chicago
Kennedy R (2004) The affective work of Stolen generations testimony: from the archives to the classroom. Biogr 27(1):48–77
Kim S (2011) Personal digital archives: preservation of documents, preservation of self. PhD Dissertation, University of Texas, Austin
Kormedy L (2007) Changes in archives’ philosophy and functions at the turn of the 20th/21st centuries. Arch Sci 7:167–177
Kwan MP (2007) Affecting geospatial technologies: towards a feminist politics of emotion. Prof Geogr 59(1):22–34
Linker M (2014) Intellectual empathy: critical thinking for social justice. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor
Love H (2009) Feeling backward: loss and the politics of queer history. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
MacNeil HM, Mak B (2007) Constructions of authenticity. Lib Q 56(1):26–52
Manalansan MF (2014) The ‘stuff’ of archives: mess, migration, and queer lives. Rad Hist Rev 120:94–107. doi:10.1215/01636545-2703742
Mankekar P (2012) Erotics, transnational media, and commodity affect. In: Mankekar P, Schein L (eds) Transnational erotics: Media and the production of ‘Asia’. Duke University Press, Durham
Mankekar P (2015) Unsettling India: affect, temporality, transnationality. Duke University Press, Durham
Masinde S, Rajan R (2008) Aluka: developing digital scholarly collections from and about Africa. Conference on Electronic Publishing and Dissemination Procs
Matthews S (2013) ‘The trophies of their wars’: affect and encounter at the Canadian war Museum. Mus Manag Curatorship 28(3):1–17
Murphy F (2011) Archives of sorrow: an exploration of Australia’s Stolen Generations and their journey into the past. Hist and Anthr 22(4):481–495
National Archives and Records Administration (2014) Strategic plan 2014-2018. http://www.archives.gov/about/plans-reports/strategic-plan/2014/nara-strategic-plan-2014-2018.pdf. Accessed 29 April 2015
Navaro-Yashin Y (2007) Make-believe papers, legal forms and the counterfeit: affective interactions between documents and people in Britain and Cyprus. Anth Theory 7(1):79–98
Nesmith T (2002) Seeing archives: postmodernism and the changing intellectual place of archives. Am Arch 65:24–41
Ngai S (2005) Ugly feelings. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
O’Neil T (2015) ‘Contract worker at National Records Center fired for mishandling draft-card information.’ St. Louis Post Dispatch. 27 Mar. http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/metro/contract-worker-at-national-records-center-fired-for-mishandling-draft/article_e059b8b8-215e-5a86-ae74-1f5a7b14a7c2.html. Accessed 29 April 2015
Orr J (2012) Feeling the archive. Emot, Sp, Soc 5(3):186–191
Pearce-Moses R (2005) Appraisal. Society of American Archivists glossary. http://www2.archivists.org/glossary/terms/a/appraisal. Accessed 27 April 2015
Pedwell C, Whitehead A (2012) Affecting feminism: questions of feeling in feminist theory. Feminist Theory 13(2):115–129
Pinney C (2014) Sepia mutiny: colonial photography and its others in India. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 71–92
Pluralizing the Archival Curriculum Group (2011) Educating for the archival multiverse. Am Arch 74:69–101
Punzalan R (2009) ‘All the things we cannot articulate’: colonial leprosy archives and community commemoration. In: Bastian J, Alexander B (eds) Community archives: the shaping of memory. Facet, London, pp 187–219
Punzalan RL, Caswell M (2016) Critical directions for archival approaches to social justice. Lib Q 86
Ramirez HR (2006) A living archive of desire. In: Burton A (ed) Archive stories: facts, fictions, and the writing of history. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 111–135
Rawlings G (2011) Statelessness, citizenship and annotated discriminations: meta documents and the aesthetics of the subtle at the United Nations. Hist Anth 22(4):461–479
Reed B (2014) Reinventing access. Arch Manus 42(2):123–132
Regan P (2010) Unsettling the settler within: Indian residential schools, truth telling, and reconciliation in Canada. University of British Columbia Press, Toronto
Robinson E (2010) Touching the void: affective history and the impossible. Rethink Hist J Theory Pract 14(4):503–520
Sedgwick EK (2003) Touching feeling: affect, pedagogy, performativity. Duke University Press, Durham
Sedgwick EK, Frank A (1995) Shame and its sisters: a silvan Tompkins reader. Duke University Press, Durham
Sheehan T (2014) Looking pleasant, feeling white: the social politics of the photographic smile. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 127–158
Smith SM (2014) Photography between desire and grief: Roland Barthes and F. Holland Day. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 29–46
Staiger J, Cvetkovich A, Reynolds AM (eds) (2010) Political emotions. Routledge, New York
Taylor D (2014) Trauma in the archive. In: Brown EH, Phu T (eds) Feeling photography. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 239–251
Trundle C, Kaplonski C (2011) Introduction: the political lives of documents. Hist Anth 22(4):407–414
Wallace D (2010) Locating agency: interdisciplinary perspectives on professional ethics and archival morality. J Info Ethics 19(1):172–189
Wallace DA, Pasick P, Berman Z, Weber E (2014) Stories for hope–Rwanda: a psychological–archival collaboration to promote healing and cultural continuity through intergenerational dialogue. Arch Sci 14(3–4):275–306
White MA (2014) Archives of intimacy and trauma: queer migration documents as technologies of affect. Rad Hist Rev 120:75–93. doi:10.1215/01636545-2703733
Yorke LK (2014) Nine hundred points of light: the Canadian community of archives. Can Iss 44–49 (Special Issue 2014)
Zembylas M (2007) The affective politics of hatred: implications for education. Intercult Ed 18(3):177–192
Zembylas M (2014) Theorizing ‘difficult knowledge’ in the aftermath of the ‘affective turn’: implications for curriculum and pedagogy in handling traumatic representations. Curriculum Inquiry 44(3):390–412
Acknowledgments
The University of California, Los Angeles’s Graduate Summer Research Mentorship Program generously funded this research. The author would like to acknowledge Michelle Caswell and Anne J. Gilliland for their mentorship, and along with those of Jesse Deshayes and Mario H. Ramirez, for their critical and constructive suggestions. Comments from two anonymous reviewers were instrumental in strengthening this piece and developing its social justice focus. The author would also like to acknowledge all who have contributed to the “Archives and Emotion” bibliography begun by Kate Theimer.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Justice is not simply a feeling. And feelings are not always just. But justice involves feelings, which move us across the surfaces of the world, creating ripples in the intimate contours of our lives. Where we go, with these feelings, remains an open question (Ahmed 2004, p. 202).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cifor, M. Affecting relations: introducing affect theory to archival discourse. Arch Sci 16, 7–31 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-015-9261-5
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-015-9261-5