Peace negotiations in the Russian invasion of Ukraine

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

There have been several rounds of peace talks to halt Russia's 2022 invasion in Ukraine and end the Russo-Ukrainian War in an armistice. The first meeting was held four days after the start of the invasion, on 28 February 2022, in Belarus. It concluded without result, with delegations from both sides returning to their capitals for consultations.[1] A second and third round of talks took place on 3[2] and 7 March 2022,[3] on the Belarus–Ukraine border, in an undisclosed location in the Gomel region of Belarus.[4] A fourth and fifth round of talks were respectively held on 10 and 14 March in Antalya, Turkey.[5][6]

Peace talks and the stability of international borders were further discussed in the Ukrainian parliament during the week of 9 May. Following the 2022 Ukrainian eastern counteroffensive, Russia renewed calls for peace talks. Ukrainian leaders refused to reopen dialogue, claiming that the Russian government was not truly committed to peace and was simply stalling for time while its forces regrouped.[7]

On 5 October 2023, the peace activist group Code Pink occupied the offices of US Senator Bernie Sanders demanding immediate peace negotiations rather than sending more weapons to the conflict zone. Since the onset of the conflict, US Congress has sent weapons in the value of 26 billion USD to Ukraine.[8]

Background[edit]

Russia was a signatory to the 1994 Budapest Memorandum political agreement, providing security assurances to Ukraine. Russia reaffirmed this assurance in 2009.[9] After the Russian occupation of Crimea began in 2014, Putin claimed that the Revolution of Dignity had created a new political entity and any prior agreement with Ukraine was therefore void.[10]

Since the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Russia has repeatedly engineered frozen conflicts to block the expansion of NATO or the European Union into the former Soviet sphere of influence.[11][12][13][14] Conflicts are deemed "frozen" when fighting has stopped but no political resolution has been achieved. In 2014, Russia orchestrated separatist movements in Ukraine,[15] and Russian proxy forces began the Donbas war.[16][11][14] After Ukraine recovered significant territory up to August 2014, Russia intervened with conventional forces, leading to negotiated ceasefires through the Minsk agreements of 2014 and 2015.[15] These ceasefires had potential to freeze the conflict, but sporadic offensives by Russia-backed separatists continued.[15] Although Russia was a party to the Minsk agreements, it later denied any obligations, claiming to have only been a mediator between Ukraine and separatist forces.[17]

In the lead-up to the invasion, Russia's president Vladimir Putin repeatedly attacked Ukraine's right to exist and referred to Ukraine as "historically Russian lands". In his July 2021 essay "On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians", he claimed there is "no historical basis" for the "idea of Ukrainian people as a nation separate from the Russians".[18]

On 24 February 2022, Russia began the Russian invasion of Ukraine as an escalation of the ongoing Russo-Ukrainian War.[19]

Negotiating positions[edit]

Russia[edit]

Shortly before the invasion, Russia demanded an international treaty to prevent Ukraine from ever joining NATO but also withdrawal of NATO from existing member states and reversal to the 1997 presence.[20][21] This was rejected by NATO as it would go against its "open-door policy" and the principle of self-determination. NATO offered to improve communication with Russia and discuss missile placements and military exercises, as long as Russia withdrew troops from Ukraine's borders.[22]

Russia's demands at the start of the invasion included recognition of Russia's annexation of Crimea, recognition of the Donetsk People's Republic and Luhansk People's Republic as independent states, as well as "demilitarization" and "denazification" of Ukraine but did not clearly specify meaning of these postulates.[23] Russian propaganda falsely claimed that Ukraine's government were neo-Nazis carrying out "genocide" in the Donbas.[24][25] An editorial "What Russia Should Do with Ukraine", published in Russian state media, explained the "denazification" as complete eradication of Ukrainian national identity.[25] Genocide scholar Eugene Finkel said the document was an admission of intent to commit genocide in Ukraine.[25] It is unclear to what extent the editorial reflected official policy, but Ukrainian-Canadian diplomat Roman Waschuk said that the appearance of the editorial around the same time as the Bucha massacre made negotiations more difficult.[25]

In September 2022 Putin's envoy on Ukraine Dmitry Kozak stated he agreed a deal that would satisfy Russia's demand for Ukraine to stay out of NATO, but the plan was rejected by Putin who preferred a full-scale military invasion.[26]

After Russia declared it had annexed the Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions of Ukraine, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that these additional annexations must be recognized before any peace plan.[27]

In April 2023, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said that he wanted any peace negotiations to focus on creating a "new world order" to counter global hegemony of the United States.[28]

In January 2024, Putin again made statements which suggested, according to the Institute for the Study of War, that his "maximalist objectives in Ukraine" remained unchanged, "which are tantamount to full Ukrainian and Western surrender". He again called for the overthrow of the Ukrainian government.[29] That same month,

Ukraine[edit]

Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy proposed in November 2022 a 10-point peace plan,[30][31] consisting of:

  1. Safety of the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant
  2. Protecting food distribution
  3. Restoration of Ukraine's energy infrastructure
  4. Release of prisoners and return of Ukrainian children deported to Russia
  5. Restoration of Ukrainian borders prior to the 2014 annexation of Crimea
  6. Full withdrawal of Russian military forces from Ukraine
  7. Prosecution of war crimes in the Russian invasion of Ukraine
  8. Remediation of ecological damage caused by the Destruction of the Kakhovka Dam
  9. Guarantees against future aggression
  10. A multilateral peace conference

Two months before the invasion, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba dismissed the idea that declaring neutrality would prevent Russian aggression. He noted that Ukraine was a neutral country in 2014 when Russia occupied Crimea and invaded the Donbas.[32] In negotiations during March and April 2022, Ukraine was willing to consider a neutral status—wherein Ukraine would not join any military alliances or host forces of other nations on its territory—if it received security guarantees from its European allies.[33] Reacting to Russian attacks on civilian targets later that year, Kuleba said, "There can be no 'neutrality' in the face of such mass war crimes. Pretending to be 'neutral' equals taking Russia's side."[27]

Zelenskyy said in August 2022 that he would not agree to a ceasefire that would freeze the conflict while Russia occupied 22% of Ukraine: "We explained that there will be no Minsk-3, Minsk-5, or Minsk-7. We will not play these games, we have lost part of our territories this way ... it is a trap."[34]

In September 2022, after Russia proclaimed it had annexed large swathes of Ukraine, Zelenskyy signed NATO application papers.[21] Ukraine has sought various security guarantees as interim measures prior to NATO accession, but there is no consensus within NATO about such an arrangement.[35]

In June 2023 Zelensky said Ukraine was not ready to negotiate with the Kremlin unless they withdrew their troops.[36] He repeated this refusal in January 2024.[37]

Timeline[edit]

Peace negotiations: First phase of invasion (24 February to 7 April 2022)[edit]

Deputy Kremlin Chief of Staff Dmitry Kozak said in 2022 that he had negotiated an agreement with Ukraine within a few days of the invasion.[38] This settlement would have ended hostilities in exchange for guarantees that Ukraine would not join NATO. The agreement was however blocked by Putin, who "expanded his objectives to include annexing swathes of Ukrainian territory".[39] A Kremlin spokesman denied the story.[38]

First round (28 February)[edit]

Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Belarusian president Alexander Lukashenko agreed on 27 February that a Ukrainian delegation would meet with Russian officials on the Belarusian border, near the Pripyat River, without preconditions.[40] It was reported that Lukashenko assured Zelenskyy that all planes, helicopters, and missiles on Belarusian territory would remain on the ground during the negotiations.[41]

Talks began on 28 February, near the Belarusian border. The Ukrainian president's office said that the main goals were to call for an immediate ceasefire, and for Russian troops to be withdrawn from Ukraine.[42] It concluded with no immediate agreements.[43]

Second round (3 March)[edit]

On 3 March, the second round of peace talks began. Both sides agreed to open humanitarian corridors for evacuating civilians.[44] Russia's demands were Ukraine's recognition of Russian-occupied Crimea, independence for separatist-controlled Luhansk and Donetsk, and "de-militarisation" and "de-Nazification". Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba stated that while his country was ready for talks to resume, Russia's demands had not changed.[23][45]

On 5 March, Naftali Bennett flew to Moscow and held three hours of meetings with Putin, then flew to Germany and held meetings with German Chancellor Olaf Scholz. Bennett spoke in advance with Zelenskyy, who had previously asked for his help mediating. He also coordinated with the US, France and Germany.[46] According to Al Monitor, the meetings were instigated by Scholz who made a brief visit to Israel on 3 March and held a long one-on-one meeting with Bennett, which produced the mediation idea.[47] Bennett said in 2023 that both sides had wanted a ceasefire, the odds of the deal holding had been 50-50, and that the Western powers backing Ukraine had stopped the deal.[48] Later he expressed doubts regarding the desirability of such a deal.[49][50]

On 6 March, Ukrainian official Denys Kireyev was found dead after being accused of committing ‘treason’ and working for Russia. Barely a week after attending the first round of peace talks, images of Kireev’s corpse began circulating.[51]

Third round (7 March)[edit]

A third round of negotiations began on 7 March, amidst ongoing fighting and bombing.[52] Dmitry Peskov restated Moscow's demands, that Ukraine should agree to change its constitution to enshrine neutrality, accept that the Crimea was Russian territory, and recognize Donetsk and Luhansk as independent states; he claimed that Russia was ready to halt military operations "in a moment" if Kyiv agreed to these conditions.[53] Although a deal had not been reached yet, Ukrainian negotiator and advisor to the president Mykhailo Podoliak tweeted that "there were some small positive shifts regarding logistics of humanitarian corridors."[3][54] However, the day before, a Ukrainian negotiator was shot amid claims of spying for Russia.[55]

Antalya Diplomacy Forum (10 March)[edit]

On 10 March, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and his Ukrainian counterpart Dmytro Kuleba met for talks in Antalya, Turkey with Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu as mediator, in the first high-level contact between the two sides since the beginning of the invasion.[5] Ukraine had attempted to negotiate a 24-hour ceasefire to provide aid and evacuation to civilians, especially in Mariupol.[56] After two hours of talks, no agreement was reached.[57] Airstrikes on the port city continued.[58]

Fourth round (14–17 March)[edit]

In the first government delegation to Ukraine since the beginning of the invasion, the prime ministers of Poland, the Czech Republic, and Slovenia met with Zelenskyy in Kyiv on 15 March 2022.[59]

The fourth round of negotiations began on 14 March via video conference. The talks lasted a few hours and ended without a breakthrough. The two sides resumed talks on 15 March,[6] after which Volodymyr Zelenskyy described the talks as beginning to "sound more realistic".[60]

By 16 March, Mykhailo Podoliak was assigned as the chief negotiator for the Ukrainian peace delegation, who indicated that peace negotiations of a 15-point plan would involve the retraction of Russian forces from their advanced positions in Ukraine, along with international guarantees for military support and alliance in case of renewed Russian military action, in return for Ukraine not pursuing further affiliation with NATO.[61]

The two sides again resumed talks on 16 March.[60] Later that day, the Financial Times reported that a 15-point plan, first discussed on 14 March, negotiated with the Russians was being identified by Zelenskyy as more realistic for ending the war.[62][63] After the fourth day of talks on 17 March, Russia said an agreement has not been reached.[64] Following the talks, French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian warned that Russia was only "pretending to negotiate", in line with a strategy it has used elsewhere.[65]

On 20 March, Turkey's Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu, the mediator of the talks, described them as "making progress". Referring to his role as "an honest mediator and facilitator", he gave little further detail.[66]

Following his address to the Israeli parliament, Zelenskyy thanked Israeli prime minister Naftali Bennett for his efforts in encouraging peace talks, and suggested that they might take place in Jerusalem.[67]

Fifth round (21 March)[edit]

The fifth round of talks, on 21 March, failed to achieve a breakthrough. Zelenskyy called for direct talks with Putin to end the war.[68] Sergey Lavrov said direct talks between the two presidents would only go ahead once both sides are closer to reaching a settlement.[69]

Renewal of peace talks: 29–30 March[edit]

Putin showing African leaders what he claims to be a 'draft peace agreement' with Ukraine, which was discussed in Turkey in 2022.[70]

On 28 March, Zelenskyy confirmed that a renewal of peace talk negotiations with Russia would start in Istanbul on 29 March, with the intention of discussing Ukrainian neutrality, along with the repudiation of any claims for Ukrainian NATO membership in the future.[71] On 29 March, Estonian Prime Minister, Kaja Kallas, indicated in agreement with French minister Le Drian that any Russian offers of peaceful negotiation about Ukraine, or withdrawal from Kyiv, should be regarded with diplomatic skepticism, based on a history of Russian unreliability in similar peace negotiations with other countries.[72][65]

Ahead of the 29 March meeting Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan stated that Ukraine was ready to agree to 4 out of Russia’s 6 demands.[73] He claimed Ukraine was prepared to renounce NATO membership and to make Russian Ukraine's second official language.[73] According to Erdoğan Ukraine was not prepared to recognise the Russian occupation of Crimea or parts of Luhansk and Donetsk Oblasts.[73] Ukraine proposed adopting a neutral status in exchange for security guarantees along the lines of NATO Article 5. The proposals also included a 15-year consultation period on the status of Russian-annexed Crimea and return of all Russian forces to their pre-invasion positions.[33] Russia's Ministry of Defense announced "drastic reduction of military activity" on the Kyiv and Chernihiv fronts, which, Russian presidential aide Vladimir Medinsky clarified, was not tantamount to a ceasefire.[74][75] In a televised meeting with military bloggers on 13 June 2023 the Russian President Vladimir Putin claimed that Russia and Ukraine had come on that day to "a good agreement on how to resolve the current situation by peaceful means" but then the Ukrainians "threw it away" after the withdrawal of Russian troops from Kyiv following the failed Russian 2022 offensive on Kyiv.[76] According to Putin, Ukraine had agreed to curb Neo-Nazism in Ukraine through the "introducing appropriate restrictions in the law in Ukraine", but this has failed to happen intentionally.[76] On 17 June 2023 Putin showed what he says was a draft agreement with Ukraine, which was discussed in Turkey late March 2022, during a meeting with an African delegation.[70] Putin claimed there were 18 articles, and "everything is spelled out, from combat equipment to the personnel of the Armed Forces of Ukraine", and the document was according to Putin signed by the head of the Ukrainian delegation.[77]

In June 2023, President of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko claimed, in an interview with Russia-1, that Ukrainian and Russian delegations also discussed the possibility of "some sort of a lease" of Crimea during the March 2022 negotiations.[73] Oleksii Arestovych, a member of the Ukrainian delegation at the talks, also said that Russia was ready for a "political discussion" concerning Crimea.[78]

Ukrainian lead negotiator (at this point) Davyd Arakhamia stated in an interview on 24 November 2023 that in March 2022 the Russian delegation had promised Ukraine peace for refusing to join NATO, but that Russia had not given any security guarantees and the Ukrainian delegation did not trust Russia to uphold such an agreement.[77][79][80] Arakhamia also refuted Putin's claim that Ukraine had signed any agreement in Turkey because the delegation did not even have the legal right to sign anything - this could only have happened if a meeting between Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Putin took place.[77] Arakhamia also claimed that Russian delegation had only cared about Ukraine's neutral status and that the other Russian demands had been "cosmetic and political "seasoning" about denazification, the Russian-speaking population and blah blah blah."[77]

Second phase of invasion (7 April to 5 September)[edit]

April 2022[edit]

On 7 April, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said that the peace deal Ukraine drafted and presented to the Russian government contained "unacceptable" elements. Lavrov said that the proposal diverged from the terms negotiators had agreed on. Mykhaylo Podolyak, a negotiator for Ukraine, said that the comments from Lavrov are a tactic to draw attention away from the war crime accusations against Russian forces. Lastly, Lavrov stated, "Despite all the provocations, the Russian delegation will continue with the negotiation process, pressing for our own draft agreement that clearly and fully outlines our initial and key positions and requirements."[81]

According to a May report from Ukrainska Pravda, the Russian side was ready for a meeting between Zelenskyy and Putin, but it later came to a halt after the discovery of War crimes in the Russian invasion of Ukraine, in particular the Bucha massacre on 1 April. In a surprise visit to Ukraine on 9 April, British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said "Putin is a war criminal, he should be pressured, not negotiated with," and that the collective West was not willing to make a deal with Putin. Three days after Johnson left Kyiv, Putin stated publicly that talks with Ukraine "had turned into a dead end". Roman Abramovich visited Kyiv in an attempt to resume negotiations. Zelenskyy proposed negotiating two separate documents, one being a bilateral agreement between Ukraine and Russia, and the other involving Ukraine and the West.[82] Ukrainian lead negotiator (at this point) Davyd Arakhamia stated in an interview on 24 November 2023 that the neutral status of Ukraine was the key Russian demand during the negotiations and that the western countries were aware of the negotiations and advised Ukraine not to rely on security guarantees. Arakhamia also denied that Johnson stopped Kyiv from signing an agreement stipulating Ukraine's neutrality saying that the Ukrainian delegation did not have the authority to do it.[77]

On 11 April, the Chancellor of Austria, Karl Nehammer, visited and spoke with Putin in Moscow in 'very direct, open and hard' talks which were skeptical of the short-term peaceful resolution of the invasion.[83] On 26 April, the Secretary-General of the United Nations António Guterres visited Russia for the purpose of speaking with Putin and Lavrov in separate meetings. After the meetings, it was revealed that Putin and Lavrov were skeptical as to reaching any short term resolution of differences between Russia and Ukraine, largely due to very different respective perspectives on the circumstances of the invasion presently being adopted by each of the two nations.[84]

According to U.S. officials who spoke to Foreign Affairs, a provisional agreement was reached in April, whereby the Russian forces would withdraw to the pre-invasion line and Ukraine would commit not to seek to join NATO in exchange for security guarantees from a number of countries. However, in a July interview with Russian state media, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov stated that this compromise was no longer an option, saying that even the Donbas was not enough and that the "geography had changed."[85]

May 2022[edit]

On 13 May, U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin initiated a telephone conversation with Russian Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu, the first call since 18 February, before the invasion. The call lasted about an hour with Austin urging an immediate ceasefire.[86][87]

On 15 May, Putin convened the Collective Security Treaty Organization, consisting of Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Armenia, Tajikistan, and Belarus, to discuss issues of peace and border security related to Ukraine and NATO.[88]

President Zelenskyy denounced suggestions by former US diplomat Henry Kissinger that Ukraine should cede control of Crimea and Donbas to Russia in exchange for peace.[89] On 25 May, Zelenskyy said that Ukraine would not agree to peace until Russia agreed to return Crimea and the Donbas region to Ukraine.[90] Zelenskyy stressed that "Ukrainians are not ready to give away their land, to accept that these territories belong to Russia." He emphasized that Ukrainians own the land of Ukraine.[91] As of September 2022. Kissinger changed his initial suggestion and presented it at the World Economic Forum in Davos in January 2023, where he announced that NATO membership for Ukraine would be an “appropriate outcome” from his perspective.[92]

Third phase of invasion (6 September to present)[edit]

September 2022[edit]

In September, Ukraine rejected a peace plan proposed by Mexico.[93]

On 21 September, Zelenskyy addressed the UN General Assembly with a pre-recorded video, laying out five "non-negotiable" conditions for a "peace formula", comprising "just punishment" of Russia for its crimes committed against Ukraine, protection of life by "all available means allowed by the UN charter", restoring security and territorial integrity, security guarantees from other countries, and determination for Ukraine to continue defending itself.[94][95] Speaking to Bild, Zelenskyy stated that he saw little chance of holding talks with Putin unless Russia withdrew its forces from Ukrainian territory.[96]

Following Putin's announcement of Russia annexing four regions of Ukrainian territory it had seized during its invasion, Zelenskyy announced that Ukraine would not hold peace talks with Russia while Putin was president.[97] Zelenskyy signed a presidential decree declaring that negotiations with Putin were "impossible", endorsing the decision of the Ukrainian National Security Council.[98] This was a response to Russia's annexation.[99]

October 2022[edit]

Following the October 2022 missile strikes on Ukraine, China and India, who had abstained from condemning Russia at the UN, expressed concern and called for de-escalation and dialogue.[100] Turkish President Erdogan expressed some hope for a diplomatic resolution, saying that Putin "is now more open to possible peace talks" and that Kyiv "was not rejecting such peace talks."[101] The Russian government announced it was ready for a renewed dialogue, and indeed had always been open to negotiating an end to hostilities.[102] The Ukrainian leadership responded that it did not believe Russia was truly committed to peace, and was simply hoping to stall for time while rebuilding its military capabilities for future offensives.[7]

On 3 October 2022, Elon Musk floated a controversial proposal on Twitter, arguing that Ukraine should permanently cede Crimea to Russia, which would be assured of its water supply from Ukraine, and that Ukraine should drop its bid to join NATO.[103] The four-part proposal, posted as a Twitter poll, suggested new referendums under UN supervision on the annexation of Russian-occupied territories.[104] The proposal was welcomed by the Russian government and rebuked by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy as "pro-Russia".[105][106][107]

November 2022[edit]

In a video address from 7 November, Ukrainian President Zelenskyy named conditions for negotiating with Russia: "One more time: restoration of territorial integrity, respect for the U.N. charter, compensation for all material losses caused by the war, punishment for every war criminal and guarantees that this does not happen again."[108][109]

U.S. Chairman of the Joint Chief of Staff Mark Milley urged Ukraine and Russia to find a "political solution", saying that the war in Ukraine is unwinnable by purely military means.[110][111]

December 2022[edit]

In a December 2022 interview with the Associated Press, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba called for a February 2023 peace summit at the UN mediated by secretary-general António Guterres. He stated that Ukraine would only invite Russia if the country faced an international court for war crimes.[112]

Putin's spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that any peace plan can only proceed from Ukraine's recognition of Russia's sovereignty over the regions it annexed from Ukraine in September 2022.[27]

On 28 December 2022, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov stated that peace talks with Ukraine would only resume if it recognized Russia's sovereignty over the annexed and partially occupied regions.[113]

January 2023[edit]

In January 2023, Putin's spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that "there is currently no prospect for diplomatic means of settling the situation around Ukraine."[114]

March 2023[edit]

On 14 March 2023, Peskov said "We have to achieve our goals. Right now this is only possible by military means due to the current position of the Kyiv regime."[115]

April 2023[edit]

Brazil's President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva suggested that Ukraine should "give up Crimea" in exchange for peace and Russia's withdrawal from the Ukrainian territory it occupied after February 2022.[116]

Andrii Sybiha, deputy head of Zelenskyy’s office, told the Financial Times: "If we will succeed in achieving our strategic goals on the battlefield and when we will be on the administrative border with Crimea, we are ready to open [a] diplomatic page to discuss this issue."[117] The official position of the Ukrainian government is that the return of Crimea is non-negotiable. In early April 2023 Ukrainian negotiator Mykhailo Podolyak called for Russia to compensate Ukraine and answer for war crimes.[118] Podolyak said Crimea should be re-taken and its new Russian inhabitants expelled.[118] At the same time, Anatol Lieven reported that some Ukrainian government officials suggested Ukraine could exchange Crimea for peace.[118]

In April 2023, Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva suggested that Ukraine should "give up Crimea" to end the war, saying Zelenskyy "can not want everything".[119] Lula condemned Russia's violation of Ukraine's territorial integrity and said Russia should withdraw from Ukrainian territory it has occupied since February 2022.[120] He said Brazil advocates a "negotiated political solution to the conflict" and expressed "concern" about the "global consequences" of the war "in terms of food and energy security, especially in the poorest regions of the planet."[121] Ukraine rejected his proposal to give up Crimea in exchange for peace.[122]

Lula proposed the creation of a "peace club" from a group of developing countries, including Brazil and China, which would try to negotiate peace in Ukraine.[116] Lula’s foreign policy adviser Celso Amorim said that "[a]s long as there are no talks, the ideal peace for the Ukrainians and the Russians will not happen. There must be concessions."[121] Lula declared after a state visit to China that "the United States needs to stop encouraging war and start talking about peace". U.S. National Security Council spokesman John Kirby responded by accusing Lula of "parroting Russian and Chinese propaganda", describing his comments as "simply misguided" and "suggesting the United States and Europe are somehow not interested in peace, or that we share responsibility for the war".[123]

Pope Francis announced that the Vatican is taking part in a secret "peace mission"

On 6 April 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine, said about a possible peace agreement between Russia and Ukraine, which would freeze the conflict and leave the annexed territories of Ukraine, including Crimea, in Russia's possession, that "If Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky proposes peace talks between Kyiv and Moscow, he will commit political suicide."[118]

On 7 April 2023, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said that Russia rejects the "unipolar world order" led by the United States and wants any peace talks with Ukraine to focus on creating a "new world order."[28]

On 30 April, Pope Francis announced that the Vatican is taking part in a secret "peace mission" to try to end the war between Russia and Ukraine.[124]

May 2023[edit]

In May 2023, UN Secretary-General António Guterres said peace negotiations to end the Russo-Ukrainian War were "not possible at this moment", saying it was clear that Russia and Ukraine "are completely absorbed in this war" and "are convinced that they can win."[125]

In May 2023, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa announced the African peace plan

On 16 May, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa announced that the leaders of African countries came up with a new initiative for peace in Ukraine.[126]

On 22 May, Denmark foreign minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen said the country was willing to host a summit in July 2023 aimed at "finding peace between Ukraine and Russia" adding that "it is necessary to build interest and involvement from countries like India, Brazil and China."[127]

On 22 May, Brazilian President Lula da Silva said that the countries of the Global South, including Brazil, India, Indonesia and China "want peace", but both Putin and Zelenskyy "are convinced that they are going to win the war" and do not want to talk about peace, so the war could be very long.[128]

June 2023[edit]

Indonesian Defense Minister Prabowo Subianto proposed a new peace initiative at the Shangri-La Dialogue security summit in Singapore

On 3 June, Indonesia's defense minister Prabowo Subianto proposed a multi-point peace plan including a ceasefire and establishing a demilitarised zone observed and monitored by the United Nations Peacekeeping Forces.[129] He said that a UN referendum should be held "to ascertain objectively the wishes of the majority of the inhabitants of the various disputed areas".[130] Prabowo's proposal was criticised by EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell.[131]

Ukrainian Defense Minister Oleksii Reznikov said that the peace plans presented by China, Brazil and Indonesia are attempts at mediation on behalf of Russia, saying that "they all currently want to be mediators on Russia’s side. That’s why this sort of mediation currently doesn’t fit for us at all because they aren’t impartial."[132] Reznikov said that Ukraine is willing to accept China as a mediator for peace talks between Russia and Ukraine only if Beijing could convince Russia to withdraw from all the territories it has occupied in Ukraine.[133]

Putin meets African leaders in St. Petersburg on 17 June 2023

In June, a delegation from Africa, including representatives from South Africa, Egypt, Senegal, Congo-Brazzaville, Comoros, Zambia, and Uganda, visited Ukraine and Russia to call for peace.[134] Both Russia and Ukraine welcomed the African leaders' mission, but Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba warned that "Any peace initiative should respect the territorial integrity of Ukraine, it should not imply, even in-between the lines, any cessation of Ukrainian territory to Russia. Second, any peace plan should not lead to the freezing of the conflict."[135] After a meeting with African leaders in Kyiv, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said that peace talks with Russia would be possible only after Moscow withdraws its forces from the entire occupied territory.[136] The African delegation was in Kyiv during a Russian missile strike on the city.[137]

On 17 June, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa and other African leaders met Russian President Vladimir Putin in St. Petersburg. Ramaphosa told Putin that the war must end,[138] but Putin rejected the delegation's peace plan based on accepting Ukraine's internationally recognized borders.[139]

July 2023[edit]

On 29 July, during a meeting with African leaders at the 2023 Russia–Africa Summit in St. Petersburg, Russian President Vladimir Putin rejected a ceasefire and peace talks with Ukraine due to the ongoing Ukrainian counter-offensive against Russian forces in Russia-occupied southeastern Ukraine, saying "We cannot cease fire when we are under attack."[140]

August 2023[edit]

On 5 and 6 August 2023 Saudi Arabia hosted multinational peace talks attended by 40 countries (including China) in Jeddah focusing on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy's proposed peace plan.[141][142] Russia did not participate in the talks.[141] Prior to the summit Andriy Yermak, Zelenskyy’s chief of staff, said there would be discussions on the Ukrainian Peace Formula, which "contains 10 fundamental points, the implementation of which will not only ensure peace for Ukraine, but also create mechanisms to counter future conflicts in the world".[143] After the summit no joint statement was issued.[141] The participants did agree to create working groups to develop details of key themes prominent in Zelenskyy's proposed peace plan (that calls for Russian troops to withdraw from all of Ukraine’s territory as part of a peace deal) while a parallel ambassadors group would continue technical work on the issues.[141]

September 2023[edit]

On 27 September 2023, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said in an interview with TASS that Russia was "ready to make agreements" on Ukraine if they would "take the situation on the ground" and Russian security interests into account.[144] According to Lavrov one of the Russian security interest was "the need to prevent the creation of a hostile Nazi regime near Russian borders."[144] Lavrov also said that Russia did not see "any serious proposals from the West" and he argued that they were promoting Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy ‘peace formula’ as "the sole basis for negotiations" and that there was "no point in discussing it as it is nothing but an ultimatum."[144] Lavrov also praised the June 2023 African, Arab League (although formally the Arab League never submitted its own peace proposal[141]), Chinese, Brazilian and peace proposals "from other countries" since he claimed "All of them were guided by a sincere desire to facilitate an agreement, which would consider the root causes of the current situation and the need to eliminate them, and will also ensure equal security for all parties."[144]

Slovakia's Prime Minister Robert Fico said that sending more and more weapons to Ukraine has only encouraged more killings and endless war, and instead efforts should be made to reach a cease-fire and push Russia and Ukraine toward peace talks. In September 2023, he stated in an interview: "Why don't we force the warring parties, use the weight of the EU and the U.S. to make them sit down and find some sort of compromise that would guarantee security for Ukraine?"[145][146] He praised the peace plans to end the war put forward by the Vatican, Brazil and China.[147] Fico said his government would do everything possible to start peace talks between Russia and Ukraine.[148]

October 2023[edit]

NBC News reported that officials at the 11 October 2023 Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting began confidential and delicate talks with the Ukrainian officials about what the broad outlines of possible peace negotiations might entail, according to two U.S. participants.[149]

November 2023[edit]

On 6 November 2023, Ukrainian President Zelenskyy rejected peace talks with Russia. He told NBC television: "I am not ready to speak with the terrorists, because their word is nothing. They have to go out from our territory, only after that, the world can switch on diplomacy."[150]

On 10 November 2023, French President Emmanuel Macron said that what Russia is doing in Ukraine is "imperialism and colonialism" and it was the "duty" of France and other countries to help Ukraine defend itself, but added that maybe the time will come to hold fair peace negotiations and find a solution with Russia.[151]

On 22 November 2023, Putin claimed that Russia was always "ready for talks" to end the "tragedy" of the war in Ukraine, and accused the Ukrainian leadership of rejecting peace talks with Russia.[152]

December 2023[edit]

On 1 December 2023, a tenth working meeting with representatives of 83 states and three international organizations on the implementation of the Ukraine's Peace Formula was held in Kyiv, Ukraine.[153]

In the 15 December 2023 annual press conference Direct Line with Vladimir Putin Russian President Putin stated “there will only be peace in Ukraine when we achieve our aims”; those "objectives do not change", he said, listing "denazification, demilitarisation and its neutral status".[154] About the September 2022 Russian annexed territories of Ukraine Putin said in the press conference that a budget allocated more than a trillion rubles ($11.15 billion) annually for the development of these (in his words) “new regions” and their “integration into the economic and social life” of Russia; he stated that "Of course, in Russia’s other regions, the situation is fundamentally better, because the authorities in Kyiv “did not give these regions the attention they were due.”[155]

On 23 December 2023, The New York Times reported that Putin has been signaling through intermediaries since at least September 2022 that "he is open to a ceasefire that freezes the fighting along the current lines."[156][157] The New York Times cited U.S. and international officials who received the message from Putin’s envoys and two former senior Russian officials close to the Kremlin.[157] A former senior Russian official told The New York Times that Putin "is willing to stop at the current positions" but is "not willing to retreat one meter."[158]

January 2024[edit]

Ukrainian President Zelenskyy said he does not feel pressure from allies to agree a ceasefire with Russia.[159] He warned that "any frozen conflict will eventually reignite".[160]

February 2024[edit]

In an interview with Tucker Carlson, Putin said he is ready to negotiate with Zelenskyy, who had previously declared that he would never negotiate with Putin. Putin urged him to reverse that decision. According to Latvia-based Russian journalist Leonid Ragozin, "Putin’s endgame appears to be getting an agreement along the lines of what has been tentatively achieved in Istanbul, but this time with all the territories which Russia occupied and formally annexed after these talks fell through. The implied threat is that Ukraine will lose even more territory – not to mention lives and infrastructure – should it keep being stubborn."[161] Putin said "We haven't achieved our [war] aims yet because one of them is denazification". According to Putin, "This means the prohibition of all kinds of neo-Nazi movements."[162] Putin did not mention in the interview that he would have conditions for peace negotiations, such as the removal of Zelenskyy's government.[163] When Carlson asked whether Putin would "be satisfied" with the territory that Russia currently occupies, Putin avoided the question and referred to his previous answer.[164]

According to Russian sources, the United States rejected Putin's proposal for a ceasefire, which reportedly was to freeze the conflict at the current frontlines and for Russia to keep the land it occupied. A US source denied there had been any official contact and said the US would not engage in talks without Ukraine.[165][166]

On 14 February 2024, the Kremlin denied reports that Putin had secretly proposed a ceasefire.[167]

March 2024[edit]

Putin's alleged secret offers to stop the fighting have contradicted what he and some members of his regime have been saying publicly.[157] On 4 March 2024, Dmitry Medvedev, Putin's deputy on the Security Council of Russia, made a speech in which he ruled out peace talks with Ukraine's current leadership. He said any future Ukrainian government that wanted talks would need to accept the Russian occupation. Medvedev described Ukraine as part of Russia,[168] and spoke in front of a large map showing Russia in control of most of the country, with western Ukraine partitioned between Poland, Hungary and Romania.[169]

Pope Francis said in an interview that Ukraine should not be ashamed to talk to Putin "before things get worse", as "the word negotiate is a courageous word", adding that "When you see that you are defeated, that things are not going well, you have to have the courage to negotiate. Negotiations are never a surrender." Polish Foreign Minister Radek Sikorski responded on X: "How about, for balance, encouraging Putin to have the courage to withdraw his army from Ukraine? Peace would immediately ensue without the need for negotiations."[170]

On 13 March 2024, Vladimir Putin said that "To negotiate just because they (Ukraine) are running out of ammunition is somehow ridiculous on our part. We are, however, ready for a serious conversation, and we want to resolve all conflicts, especially this conflict, through peaceful means. But we must clearly understand that it shouldn’t be a break for the enemy to rearm but a serious talk involving security guarantees for the Russian Federation."[171] Responding to Putin's words, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz's spokesman said that Putin "can end this war immediately at any time by canceling his (military) campaign, withdrawing his troops (from Ukraine), and going to the negotiating table."[171]

Copenhagen format meetings[edit]

The Ukrainian Peace Plan has been publicized at a series of meetings that began on 25 June 2023;[172][173] the conference, which was held in Copenhagen, was attended by 15 countries.[174] The conference series has been given the name Copenhagen format as a result by some news outlets. The second meeting in Copenhagen format was held in Jeddah on 6 August 2023; China along with about 40 countries participated there.[175] The next meeting was held in Malta on 28 October 2023,[176][177] with 65 nations in attendance.[178] The next meeting in this format was held in Davos at the World Economic Forum in January 2024; delegates from 83 nations were present.[179][180]

Chinese peace proposal[edit]

In February 2023, during a speech at the 59th Munich Security Conference, Chinese foreign policy chief, CCP Politburo member Wang Yi said that CCP general secretary Xi Jinping would present a “peace proposal” to resolve what he described as the "conflict" between Moscow and Kyiv.[181][182]

Chinese peace envoy Li Hui meets with Ukrainian foreign minister Dmytro Kuleba in Kyiv (17 May 2023)

At the UN General Assembly marking the anniversary of the invasion, Chinese deputy UN ambassador proposed China's plan including a ceasefire, dialogue, security guarantees for Russia, protection of civilians and the upholding of territorial integrity, while also insisting that the West was exacerbating the situation by sending weapons to Ukraine.[183][184] On Feb 24, the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs published as a 12-point position paper on its website titled "China’s Position on the Political Settlement of the Ukraine Crisis", getting mixed responses from Western leaders.[185][186] President Zelenskyy stated "I plan to meet Xi Jinping and believe this will be beneficial for our countries and for security in the world", although a time and place for such meeting was not set.[187]

Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova responded saying Russia appreciated Beijing's effort to resolve the conflict by peaceful means and was "open to achieving the goals of the special military operation by political and diplomatic means" but that it would entail recognising "new territorial realities" in Ukraine, referring to Russia's annexation of Donetsk, Kherson, Luhansk and Zaporizhzhia oblasts.[188] Putin's spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that "for now, we don't see any of the conditions that are needed to bring this whole story towards peace."[189]

On 7 March 2023, China's Foreign Minister Qin Gang remarked, "the Ukraine crisis seems to be driven by an invisible hand pushing for the protraction and escalation of the conflict." He insisted that sanctions and political pressure will not solve the problem. Qin also said Beijing has not provided weapons to either side of the Ukraine conflict. He added that "the process of peace talks should begin as soon as possible". The PRC has called for peace negotiations since the conflict began to address the legitimate security concerns of all parties involved.[190]

Prior to his visit to Russia on 20-22 March 2023, Xi Jinping said China's peace proposal to end the Russo-Ukrainian War reflected world opinion.[191] U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken questioned China's peace proposal, saying "the world should not be fooled by any tactical move by Russia, supported by China or any other country, to freeze the war on its own terms."[192]

On 26 April 2023, Chinese leader Xi Jinping called Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, over a month after Xi's summit with Russia's President Vladimir Putin.[193] According to Steve Tsang, director of the SOAS China Institute in London, "There is no indication that Xi is trying to get Putin or Russia to make concessions of any sort (and) the Chinese readout (of the call) does not include anything concrete that can start a peace process."[194]

In May 2023, European officials reportedly criticized China's peace plan as an attempt at "freezing" the conflict in place and splitting the West in pushing Ukraine cease-fire.[195][196]

Agreements regarding grain exports[edit]

Russia and Ukraine signed agreements with Turkey and the United Nations on 22 July 2022, intended to secure exports via the Black Sea of grain from both countries and fertilizer from Russia, to ease shortages in developing countries.[197] The next day, Russia fired missiles at the port city of Odesa, through which Ukrainian grain flows[198] and formally declared Ukrainian ports unsafe.[199] As a result of the agreement, the first shipment of Ukraine grain to international destinations started on 1 August 2022.[200]

Opinion polls[edit]

In the poll conducted by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology (KIIS) between 13 and 18 May 2022, 82% of Ukrainians said they did not support any territorial concessions to Russia, even if that meant prolonging the war.[201] Another KIIS poll conducted in September 2022 found that 87% of Ukrainians opposed any territorial concessions to Russia.[202] A Gallup poll conducted in Ukraine in early September 2022 showed that 70% of Ukrainians want to continue the war with Russia until they achieve victory, while only 26% favor negotiations to end the war as soon as possible.[203] According to an opinion poll conducted in July 2022, 58% of Ukrainians said that Crimea must be returned to Ukraine.[118]

According to a survey conducted by the Levada Center at the end of October 2022, 57% of Russian respondents favored the start of peace talks with Ukraine, and 36% preferred the continuation of hostilities.[204] The Kremlin's analysis concluded that public support in Russia for the war was broad but not deep, and that most Russians would accept anything Putin would call a victory. In September 2023, the head of the VTsIOM state pollster Valery Fyodorov said in an interview that only 10-15% of Russians actively supported the war, and that "most Russians are not demanding the conquest of Kyiv or Odesa."[157]

A poll of Germans conducted by the Forsa and published in January 2023 found that over 80% believe it is more important to end the war through negotiations than for Ukraine to win, with only 18% disagreeing.[205] A YouGov poll showed that in February 2023, 63% of respondents in Sweden wanted to support Ukraine in a war with Russia until Russian troops leave all occupied territories, even if it means prolonging the war. In Denmark, the corresponding figures were 56%; in Britain 53%, in the United States 46%, in Spain 44%; Germany 40%, France 37% and Italy 29%.[206]

In fall 2023, US public support for arming Ukraine in its war against Russia significantly decreased. Support for U.S. weapon shipments to Ukraine dropped from 46% to 41% compared to a poll taken in May 2023. Both sides of the political spectrum saw a decline. Since the counteroffensive started in June 2023, Ukrainian forces have only retaken a series of small villages and settlements and are only in control of a small percentage of the territories occupied by Russian forces.[207]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Hopkins, Valerie (28 February 2022). "Initial talks between Russia and Ukraine yield no resolution". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 16 March 2022.
  2. ^ Reevell, Patrick; Hutchinson, Bill (2 March 2022). "2nd round of talks between Russia and Ukraine end with no cease-fire". ABC News. Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  3. ^ a b "Ukraine and Russia hold third round of talks". Deutsche Welle. Reuters, Agence France-Presse, Deutsche Presse-Agentur. 7 March 2022. Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  4. ^ Roshchina, Olena (28 February 2022). Переговори делегацій України та Росії почалися [Negotiations between the delegations of Ukraine and Russia began]. Українська правда [Ukrainska Pravda] (in Ukrainian). Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 7 March 2022. Деталі: Переговори відбуваються на Гомельщині на березі річки Прип'ять. Із міркувань безпеки точне місце організатори переговорів не називають. [Details: Negotiations are taking place in the Gomel region on the banks of the Pripyat River. For security reasons, the organizers of the talks did not name the exact location.]
  5. ^ a b "'No progress' as top Russia, Ukraine diplomats talk in Turkey". Al Jazeera. 10 March 2022. Archived from the original on 15 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  6. ^ a b Karmanau, Yuras (14 March 2022). "Russia keeps up attacks in Ukraine as two sides hold talks". Associated Press. Archived from the original on 16 March 2022. Retrieved 16 March 2022.
  7. ^ a b "Why Russia is pushing a return to negotiations The Kremlin wants to buy time to prepare for a 'full-scale offensive' in early 2023, sources say". Meduza. Retrieved 26 October 2022.
  8. ^ "Top US & World Headlines". Democracy Now. 5 October 2023. Retrieved 6 October 2023 – via YouTube.com.
  9. ^ "Budapest Memorandums on Security Assurances, 1994 - Council on Foreign Relations". Cfr.org. 5 December 1994. Archived from the original on 12 March 2017. Retrieved 7 March 2017.
  10. ^ Borger, Julian (5 May 2023). "We knew in 2011 Putin would attack Ukraine, says Bill Clinton". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Archived from the original on 6 May 2023. Retrieved 6 May 2023.
  11. ^ a b Jukic, Luka (20 February 2019). "How Russia Keeps Post-Soviet States in Its Orbit". Palladium Magazine. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  12. ^ Orttung, Robert; Walker, Christopher (13 February 2015). "Putin's Frozen Conflicts". Foreign Policy. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  13. ^ "Post-Soviet Frozen Conflicts" (PDF). Per Concordiam. 3 (4): 42.
  14. ^ a b Grossman, Erik J. (1 June 2018). "Russia's Frozen Conflicts and the Donbas". The US Army War College Quarterly: Parameters. 48 (2). doi:10.55540/0031-1723.2944.
  15. ^ a b c Kofman, Michael; Migacheva, Katya; Nichiporuk, Brian. "Lessons from Russia's Operations in Crimea and Eastern Ukraine" (PDF). RAND Corporation.
  16. ^ Kirby, Paul (26 May 2022). "Donbas: Why Russia is trying to capture eastern Ukraine". BBC. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  17. ^ Merezhko, Oleksandr (14 July 2020). "Russo-Ukrainian War: Kremlin denials prevent progress towards peace". Atlantic Council. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  18. ^ Düben, B A. "Revising History and ‘Gathering the Russian Lands’: Vladimir Putin and Ukrainian Nationhood". LSE Public Policy Review, vol. 3, no. 1, 2023 accessed 25 February 2024
  19. ^ Hodge, Nathan; Lister, Tim; Kottasová, Ivana; Regan, Helen. "Russia launches military attack on Ukraine with reports of explosions and troops crossing border". CNN. Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022. Russian forces have begun an attack on Ukraine, with reports of troops crossing the border to the north and south, explosions in multiple cities including the capital Kyiv and warnings from Russian President Vladimir Putin of bloodshed unless Ukrainian forces lay down their arms.
  20. ^ "Russia demands NATO roll back from East Europe and stay out of Ukraine". Reuters. 17 December 2021. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  21. ^ a b Balmforth, Tom (30 September 2022). "Ukraine applies for NATO membership, rules out Putin talks". Reuters. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  22. ^ "US offers no concessions in response to Russia on Ukraine". Associated Press. 26 January 2022. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  23. ^ a b "Ukrainian and Russian delegates leave latest peace talks feeling 'great regret'". ABC News (Australia). 3 March 2022. Archived from the original on 15 March 2022. Retrieved 8 March 2022.
  24. ^ Smart, Charlie (2 July 2022). "How the Russian Media Spread False Claims About Ukrainian Nazis". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 3 July 2022.
  25. ^ a b c d Brown, Chris (5 April 2022). "A Kremlin paper justifies erasing the Ukrainian identity, as Russia is accused of war crimes". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
  26. ^ "Exclusive: As war began, Putin rejected a Ukraine peace deal recommended by aide". 14 September 2022.
  27. ^ a b c "British Defense Ministry Notes 'Continued Churn of Senior Russian Officials'". VOA News. 30 December 2022.
  28. ^ a b "Any Ukraine Peace Talks Should Be About 'New World Order' – Lavrov". The Moscow Times. 7 April 2023.
  29. ^ "Institute for the Study of War: Putin calls again for overthrow of Ukrainian government – Baltimore Council on Foreign Affairs". bcfausa.org.
  30. ^ Shashkova, Maryna (13 August 2023). "EXPLAINED: Zelensky's 10-Point Peace Plan". Kyiv Post.
  31. ^ "What is Zelenskyy's 10-point peace plan?". Al Jazeera.
  32. ^ Kuleba, Dmytro (10 December 2021). "Don't Sell Out Ukraine". Foreign Affairs. Council on Foreign Relations.
  33. ^ a b "Ukraine offers neutrality in exchange for NATO-style security guarantees at Russia talks". Reuters. 29 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  34. ^ Lock, Samantha (23 August 2022). "Russia-Ukraine war latest: what we know on day 182 of the invasion". The Guardian.
  35. ^ Bayer, Lili (8 June 2023). "The West isn't ready to give Ukraine the security pledges it wants". Politico.
  36. ^ "Ukraine's Zelensky 'not ready' for talks with Moscow unless troops withdraw". France 24. 5 November 2023.
  37. ^ "'We couldn't survive without US help', President Zelenskyy tells Channel 4 News (extended interview)" – via www.youtube.com.
  38. ^ a b Times, The Moscow (14 September 2022). "Putin Rejected Early Ukraine Peace Deal to Pursue 'Expanded' Annexation Goals – Reuters". The Moscow Times. Retrieved 14 September 2022.
  39. ^ "Exclusive: As war began, Putin rejected a Ukraine peace deal recommended by aide". Reuters. 14 September 2022. Retrieved 14 September 2022.
  40. ^ Zinets, Natalia; Williams, Matthias (27 February 2022). Williams, Alison (ed.). "Ukraine and Russia agree to talks without preconditions, Zelenskiy says". Reuters. Archived from the original on 13 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  41. ^ "Ukrainians agree to meet for talks with Russia on Belarus border". The Times of Israel. 27 February 2022. OCLC 969749342. Archived from the original on 10 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  42. ^ "Ukraine and Russia finish the first round of peace talks at Belarusian border, next round to be held in days". ABC News (Australia). Reuters, Associated Press. 28 February 2022. Archived from the original on 9 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  43. ^ "No breakthrough at Ukraine talks as Russian assault continues". Al Jazeera. 28 February 2022. Archived from the original on 15 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  44. ^ Lawler, Dave (3 March 2022). "Russia agreed to open "humanitarian corridors" for fleeing civilians: Ukraine official". Axios. Archived from the original on 12 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  45. ^ Aris, Ben (4 March 2022). "Second round of Russia, Ukraine peace talks ends with no progress, assault on Kyiv looms". bne IntelliNews. Archived from the original on 8 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  46. ^ Lahav Harkov (6 March 2022). "Bennett concludes meeting with Putin, speaks with Zelenskyy". Jerusalem Post.
  47. ^ "Germany's Scholz behind Israel's Bennett shuttle diplomacy on Ukraine - Al-Monitor: Independent, trusted coverage of the Middle East". www.al-monitor.com. 11 March 2022. Retrieved 7 March 2023.
  48. ^ "The Grinding War in Ukraine Could Have Ended a Long Time Ago". Jacobin. 8 February 2023. Retrieved 25 February 2023.
  49. ^ "Naftali Bennett". Twitter. Retrieved 25 February 2023.
  50. ^ Naftali Bennett. "Bennett speaks out". Youtube (in Hebrew). Retrieved 28 December 2023.
  51. ^ Hayley Taylor (7 March 2022). "Ukrainian official Denis Kireev found dead after being accused of committing 'treason' and working for Russia- Barely a week after attending the first round of peace talks between Russia and Ukraine, images of Denis Kireev's lifeless body began circulating". 7news.com.au. Retrieved 29 November 2023.
  52. ^ Patteson, Callie (7 March 2022). "Little progress in new peace talks — as Russia unleashes 'medieval siege warfare'". New York Post. ISSN 1090-3321. Archived from the original on 8 March 2022. Retrieved 8 March 2022.
  53. ^ Belton, Catherine (7 March 2022). "Russia will stop 'in a moment' if Ukraine meets terms - Kremlin". Reuters. Retrieved 13 April 2023.
  54. ^ Karmanau, Yuras (7 March 2022). "3rd round of peace talks wrap up as Ukrainian civilians continue to flee Russian shelling". Global News. Associated Press. Archived from the original on 9 March 2022. Retrieved 15 March 2022.
  55. ^ Waterfield, Bruno (7 March 2022). "Ukrainians 'kill negotiator as suspected enemy spy'". The Times. London.
  56. ^ "Ukraine war: No progress on ceasefire after Kyiv-Moscow talks". BBC News. 10 March 2022. Archived from the original on 15 March 2022. Retrieved 16 March 2022.
  57. ^ Ellyatt, Holly (10 March 2022). "Russia-Ukraine talks fail with no progress on cease-fire, safe passage for civilians". CNBC. Archived from the original on 15 March 2022. Retrieved 16 March 2022.
  58. ^ Brown, Lee (10 March 2022). "Ukraine-Russia peace talks fail to make progress as airstrikes continue on Mariupol". New York Post. ISSN 1090-3321. Archived from the original on 13 March 2022. Retrieved 16 March 2022.
  59. ^ Oatis, Jonathan, ed. (15 March 2022). "Poland's Kaczynski calls for peacekeeping mission in Ukraine". Reuters. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  60. ^ a b "Zelensky: Peace talks 'sound more realistic'". BBC News. 16 March 2022. Archived from the original on 16 March 2022. Retrieved 16 March 2022.
  61. ^ "What could a Ukraine-Russia peace agreement look like?". TRT World. 18 March 2022. Archived from the original on 21 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  62. ^ Reed, John; Olearchyk, Roman; Shotter, James; Schwartz, Felicia (16 March 2022). "Zelensky says Ukrainian and Russian positions becoming more 'realistic'". Financial Times. ISSN 0307-1766. Archived from the original on 25 March 2022. Retrieved 25 March 2022.
  63. ^ "Russia-Ukraine peace talks 'sounding more realistic': Zelenskyy". Al Jazeera. 16 March 2022. Archived from the original on 23 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  64. ^ Mackenzie, James; Zinets, Natalia; Kozhukhar, Oleksandr (17 March 2022). Graff, Peter; MacSwan, Angus; Janowski, Tomasz; Jones, Gareth (eds.). "Scant progress in peace talks as Ukrainian cities pounded in more Russian attacks". Reuters. Archived from the original on 21 March 2022. Retrieved 21 March 2022.
  65. ^ a b RFI (17 March 2022). "French Foreign Minister says Russia is 'pretending to negotiate' in Ukraine talks". Radio France Internationale. AFP. Archived from the original on 25 March 2022. Retrieved 25 March 2022.
  66. ^ "Ukraine and Russia make progress on negotiations - Turkey". BBC News. 20 March 2022. Archived from the original on 20 March 2022. Retrieved 28 March 2022.
  67. ^ Popeski, Ron; Kelly, Lidia; Kozhukhar, Oleksandr (28 March 2022). Coates, Stephan (ed.). "Zelenskiy suggests Israel as good place to hold talks with Russia". Reuters. Archived from the original on 27 March 2022. Retrieved 28 March 2022.
  68. ^ Dutta, Prabhash K. (22 March 2022). "Why Russia, Ukraine don't agree in peace talks to end war". India Today. Archived from the original on 26 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  69. ^ "Putin-Zelenskiy meeting needed once sides closer on key issues, Lavrov says". Reuters. 28 March 2022. Archived from the original on 29 March 2022. Retrieved 28 March 2022.
  70. ^ a b "Latest in Ukraine: Putin, Zelenskyy Reject African Peace Initiative". VOA News. 18 June 2023.
  71. ^ Lock, Samantha; Boffey, Daniel (28 March 2022). "Zelenskiy says Ukraine willing to discuss neutrality at Russia talks". The Guardian. Lviv. Retrieved 28 March 2022.
  72. ^ Kallas, Kaja (29 March 2022). "Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas on war in Ukraine and the Russian threat". PBS NewsHour (Interview). Interviewed by Judy Woodruff. Archived from the original on 30 March 2022. Retrieved 30 March 2022.
  73. ^ a b c d "Lukashenko says Russia and Ukraine could have agreed on "leasing" Crimea". Ukrainska Pravda. 14 June 2023. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
  74. ^ "Russia says it will "drastically reduce" military assault on Kyiv and Chernihiv". CNN. 29 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  75. ^ "It's now 10 p.m. in Kyiv. Here are the latest developments in the war in Ukraine". CNN. 29 March 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
  76. ^ a b "Putin called "not bad" the agreement reached in March 2022 between Russia and Ukraine". TASS (in Russian). 13 June 2023. Retrieved 13 June 2023.
    "The President of the Russian Federation clarified that during the 2022 negotiations between the Russian and Ukrainian sides, Moscow regularly raised the issue that Kyiv supports the neo-Nazi movement". TASS (in Russian). 13 June 2023. Retrieved 13 June 2023.
  77. ^ a b c d e "Arakhamia stated that the Russians lured Ukraine with "peace" for neutrality". Ukrainska Pravda. 24 October 2023. Retrieved 24 November 2023.
  78. ^ "Арестович: Почему нет плана на 2024 год? День 643" [Arestovich: Why is there no plan for 2024? Day 643]. Youtube (in Russian). Alexey Arestovych. Retrieved 29 November 2023.
  79. ^ "Ukrainian negotiator: Russia promised peace if Ukraine dropped NATO aspirations". The Jerusalem Post. 27 November 2023. Retrieved 27 November 2023.
  80. ^ "Russia Offered to End War in 2022 If Ukraine Scrapped NATO Ambitions – Zelensky Party Chief". Kyiv Post. 26 November 2023. Retrieved 27 November 2023.
  81. ^ "Russia says Ukraine presented 'unacceptable' draft peace deal". Reuters. 7 April 2022. Retrieved 7 April 2022.
  82. ^ ROMAN ROMANIUK (5 May 2022). "Possibility of talks between Zelenskyy and Putin came to a halt after Johnson's visit - UP sources". Ukrainska Pravda. Retrieved 8 September 2023.
  83. ^ Nadine Schmidt, Nic Robertson and Rob Picheta (11 April 2022). "Austria's leader says his face-to-face meeting with Putin was 'not a friendly visit'". CNN. Retrieved 28 April 2022.
  84. ^ "U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres signals little hope for peace in Ukraine before meeting Putin in Moscow". www.cbsnews.com. 26 April 2022. Retrieved 28 April 2022.
  85. ^ Fiona Hill; Angela Stent (25 August 2022). "The World Putin Wants". Foreign Affairs.
  86. ^ Mitchell, Ellen (13 May 2022). "Austin speaks with Russian counterpart for first time since start of war in Ukraine". The Hill. Washington DC. Retrieved 15 May 2022.
  87. ^ "Readout of Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III's Call With Russian Minister of Defense Sergey Shoygu". Department of Defense. 13 May 2022. Retrieved 15 May 2022.
  88. ^ Merkel, David A. (15 May 2022). "Will 'Putin's Nato' follow Warsaw Pact into obscurity?". EU Observer. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
  89. ^ Bostock, Bill (26 May 2022). "Zelenskyy slams Henry Kissinger for emerging 'from the deep past' to suggest Ukraine cede territory to Russia". Business Insider. Archived from the original on 26 May 2022. Retrieved 29 May 2022.
  90. ^ "Zelenskyy rejects Kissinger plan to concede territory to Russia; Ukraine hero alive, in Russian custody: Live updates". USA Today. 25 May 2022. Retrieved 8 September 2023.
  91. ^ "Exclusive: Zelensky says Ukraine will not give up territory for peace with Russia". 7 July 2022. Retrieved 8 September 2023.
  92. ^ Pietrzak, Piotr. "Henry Kissinger's Shift on Ukraine and Its Implications for Russia: The Commencement but Not a Conclusion of the Sixth Great Debate in International Relations." In Analyzing Global Responses to Contemporary Regional Conflicts, edited by Piotr Pietrzak, 133-162. Hershey, PA: IGI Global, 2024. https://doi.org/10.4018/979-8-3693-2837-8.ch007
  93. ^ "Mexico Foreign Minister Meets Russia's Lavrov to Discuss Ukraine Peace Plan". U.S. News. 23 September 2022.
  94. ^ "Zelenskiy addresses UN, lays out Ukraine conditions for peace – video". The Guardian. 22 September 2022.
  95. ^ Під час виступу на засіданні Генасамблеї ООН Володимир Зеленський представив українську формулу миру [During his speech at the UN General Assembly, Volodymyr Zelenskyy presented the Ukrainian formula for peace], retrieved 15 November 2023 – via YouTube
  96. ^ "Ukraine's Zelenskiy sees dwindling chance of peace talks with Putin". Reuters. 21 September 2022.
  97. ^ "Ukraine applies for Nato membership after Russia annexes territory". TheGuardian.com. 30 September 2022.
  98. ^ Nova, Redazione Agenzia (4 October 2022). "Ukraine, Zelensky signs the decree on the "impossibility of conducting negotiations" with Russia".
  99. ^ "Ukraine rules out peace talks after Russia claims part of country". www.washingtonpost.com. 4 October 2022. Retrieved 18 February 2024.
  100. ^ Mashal, Mujib (10 October 2022). "India and China, which have refrained from criticizing Russia, call for de-escalation". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 14 October 2022.
  101. ^ "Türkiye hopeful for truce between Ukraine-Russia, Erdoğan says - Türkiye News". 21 October 2022.
  102. ^ "'Much softer': Is Russia eyeing a way out of the Ukraine war?". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 26 October 2022.
  103. ^ Musk, Elon [@elonmusk] (3 October 2022). "Ukraine-Russia Peace: - Redo elections of annexed regions under UN supervision. Russia leaves if that is will of the people. - Crimea formally part of Russia, as it has been since 1783 (until Khrushchev's mistake). - Water supply to Crimea assured. - Ukraine remains neutral" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 8 December 2022. Retrieved 8 December 2022 – via Twitter.
  104. ^ Wilson, Joseph (4 October 2022). "Musk's plan to end Russian war infuriates Ukraine on Twitter". ABC News. Associated Press. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  105. ^ "Kremlin welcomes Elon Musk proposal for Ukraine settlement denounced by Kyiv". Reuters. 4 October 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  106. ^ "Elon Musk's peace plan for Ukraine draws condemnation from Zelenskyy". NPR. Associated Press. 4 October 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  107. ^ Duffy, Kate. "Kremlin praises Elon Musk for his controversial Twitter poll that included suggestions for a Ukraine 'peace plan'". Business Insider. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  108. ^ "Zelensky sets high bar for any peace talks with Putin". Axios. 8 November 2022.
  109. ^ "100,000 Russian troops killed or injured in Ukraine, US says". Associated Press. 10 November 2022.
  110. ^ "Ukraine Military Victory Unlikely Soon, Top US General Says". VOA News. 16 November 2022.
  111. ^ "Russia's Losses Give Ukraine an Opening for Negotiations, Top US General Says". Bloomberg. 16 November 2022.
  112. ^ Castillo, E. Eduardo; Hanna Arhirova (26 December 2022). "The AP Interview: Ukraine FM aims for February peace summit". APNews.com. Associated Press. Retrieved 26 December 2022.
  113. ^ "Moscow To Achieve Ukraine Goals Thanks to 'Patience' - Lavrov". The Moscow Times. 28 December 2022.
  114. ^ "There are currently no prospects for diplomatic solution to situation around Ukraine, - Peskov". Censor.NET. 25 January 2023. Retrieved 13 February 2023.
  115. ^ "Kremlin: for Now, Goals in Ukraine Can Only Be Achieved by Military Force". U.S. News. Reuters. 14 March 2023.
  116. ^ a b "Brazil's Lula Visits China With Ukraine Peace Talks On His Agenda". Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. 13 April 2023.
  117. ^ "Ukraine 'ready' to talk to Russia on Crimea if counteroffensive succeeds". Financial Times. 5 April 2023. Retrieved 23 April 2023.
  118. ^ a b c d e Lieven, Anatol (11 April 2023). "Crimea Has Become a Frankenstein's Monster". Foreign Policy.
  119. ^ "'The world needs tranquillity': Ukraine urged to give up Crimea by Brazil's Lula". Euronews. 7 April 2023. Archived from the original on 8 April 2023. Retrieved 23 April 2023.
  120. ^ Osborn, Catherine (7 April 2023). "Can Brazil Negotiate an End to the War in Ukraine?". Foreign Policy. Retrieved 23 April 2023.
  121. ^ a b "Brazil condemns 'violation' of Ukraine's territory amid criticism". Al Jazeera. 19 April 2023. Retrieved 23 April 2023.
  122. ^ "Brazil's Lula condemns invasion of Ukraine, touts peace initiative". Reuters. 19 April 2023. Retrieved 23 April 2023.
  123. ^ "Ukraine war: US accuses Lula of parroting propaganda". BBC News. 18 April 2023.
  124. ^ "Pope says Vatican involved in secret Ukraine peace mission". Reuters. 30 April 2023.
  125. ^ "Russia Holds Victory Day Celebrations Amid Fresh Strikes On Ukraine". Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. 9 May 2023.
  126. ^ "African Nations Plan Russia-Ukraine Peace Mission, Ramaphosa Says". Bloomberg. 16 May 2023.
  127. ^ Gronholt-pedersen, Jacob (22 May 2023). "Denmark offers to host Ukraine peace talks, wants India, China, Brazil to attend". Reuters. Retrieved 9 June 2023.
  128. ^ "Lula 'upset' after Zelenskyy's no-show to Hiroshima meeting". EFE. 22 May 2023.
  129. ^ McBeth, John (8 June 2023). "No takers for Prabowo's offbeat Ukraine peace plan". Asia Times.
  130. ^ "Indonesia proposes demilitarised zone, UN referendum for Ukraine peace plan". Reuters. 3 June 2023.
  131. ^ "Ukraine dismisses 'strange' Indonesian peace plan". The Jakarta Post. 4 June 2023.
  132. ^ "Chinese and Indonesian 'peace plans' really just Russia proxies, says DM Reznikov at NV event". The New Voice of Ukraine. 8 June 2023.
  133. ^ "If Xi gets Putin to send Russia's troops home, he can broker peace: Ukraine Defence Minister". The Straits Times. 5 June 2023.
  134. ^ "Ukraine war must end, South African President Ramaphosa tells Putin". BBC. 18 June 2023. Retrieved 18 June 2023.
  135. ^ "African Leaders Head to Ukraine, Russia on Peace Mission". VOA News. 14 June 2023.
  136. ^ "Ukraine tells African leaders no peace talks with Russia". Reuters. 16 June 2022.
  137. ^ "African delegation in Eastern Europe: More than a photo op?". Deutsche Welle. 18 June 2023.
  138. ^ "South Africa's Ramaphosa tells Vladimir Putin to stop war in Ukraine as African delegation arrives in Moscow to plead for peace". Sky News. 18 June 2023.
  139. ^ "Putin rebuts key elements of African peace plan for Ukraine". Reuters. 18 June 2023.
  140. ^ "No cease-fire while Ukraine is on the offensive, Putin declares". Politico. 30 July 2023.
  141. ^ a b c d e "Saudi peace talks put Ukraine territorial integrity at the core of any deal with Russia". bne IntelliNews. 6 August 2023. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
  142. ^ "Saudi Arabia and Turkey are emerging as the new peace brokers of the Russia-Ukraine war". CNBC. 1 August 2023.
  143. ^ "Saudi Arabia to host Ukraine peace talks, top official says". Al Jazeera. 31 July 2023.
  144. ^ a b c d "Russia ready to make agreements on Ukraine based on situation on ground — Lavrov". TASS. 27 September 2023. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
    "Russia sees no serious Western proposals on talks on Ukraine — Lavrov". TASS. 28 September 2023. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
  145. ^ "Slovakia's Election Threatens to Upend Western Unity on Ukraine". Voice of America. 27 September 2023.
  146. ^ "We won't send another bullet to Kyiv, says Slovakia's PM frontrunner". The Daily Telegraph. 29 September 2023.
  147. ^ "Fico says West's arms deliveries to Kyiv 'supports killings'". Euractiv. 18 May 2023.
  148. ^ "Slovakia's poll winner defies European consensus on Ukraine". Reuters. 1 October 2023.
  149. ^ Kube, Courtney; Lee, Carol E.; Welker, Kristen (3 November 2023). "U.S., European officials broach topic of peace negotiations with Ukraine, sources say". NBC News. Retrieved 4 November 2023.
  150. ^ "Ukraine's Zelensky 'not ready' for talks with Moscow unless troops withdraw". France 24. 6 November 2023.
  151. ^ "Macron calls on Israel to stop killing Gaza's women and babies". BBC News. 11 November 2023.
  152. ^ "Putin calls war a 'tragedy'; Moscow claims Ukraine is seeing 'colossal losses' after crossing river". CNBC. 22 November 2023.
  153. ^ "Zelenskyy's team reports progress in Ukraine's Peace Formula talks: Advancements in 9 key points". RBC-Ukraine. 1 December 2023. Retrieved 1 December 2023.
  154. ^ "Putin says no peace until Russia's goals in Ukraine achieved". The Guardian. 14 December 2023. Retrieved 15 December 2023.
    "Russia-Ukraine war: Putin tells Russia his war objectives are unchanged". BBC News. 14 December 2023. Retrieved 15 December 2023.
  155. ^ "Putin and the people The Kremlin stages its end-of-the-year marathon press conference, combined with a televised call-in show, to showcase Russia's presidency". Meduza. 14 December 2023. Retrieved 15 December 2023.
  156. ^ "Putin Quietly Signaling Openness to Ukraine Ceasefire Talks – NYT". The Moscow Times. 23 December 2023.
  157. ^ a b c d "Putin Quietly Signals He Is Open to a Cease-Fire in Ukraine". The New York Times. 23 December 2023.
  158. ^ "Vladimir Putin open to ceasefire negotiations with Ukraine: Report". WION. 24 December 2023.
  159. ^ "Zelenskiy Sees No Pressure to Freeze War as Putin Presses On". Bloomberg. 10 January 2024.
  160. ^ "Putin's war must not become 'frozen,' Zelensky warns as Ukraine's troops face shortages of weaponry and aid". CNN. 16 January 2024.
  161. ^ "Putin is ready for talks on Ukraine, but on his own terms". Al Jazeera. 12 February 2024.
  162. ^ "Tucker Carlson Shares Controversial Two-Hour Vladimir Putin Interview". Variety. 8 February 2024.
  163. ^ Crowley, Michael (9 February 2024). "U.S. Rejects Putin's Latest Call for Ukraine Negotiations". The New York Times.
  164. ^ Hartog, Eva; Goryashko, Sergey (9 February 2024). "Tucker Carlson's Putin interview: 9 takeaways". Politico Europe. Retrieved 23 February 2024.
  165. ^ "Exclusive: Putin's suggestion of Ukraine ceasefire rejected by United States, sources say". Reuters. 13 February 2024.
  166. ^ "US rejects Putin's proposal to cease fire after meeting of mediators – Reuters". Ukrainska Pravda. 13 February 2024.
  167. ^ "Kremlin denies Reuters report that Putin offered a ceasefire in Ukraine". Reuters. 14 February 2024.
  168. ^ "Putin ally says 'Ukraine is Russia' and historical territory needs to 'come home'". Reuters. 4 March 2024.
  169. ^ "'Ukraine Is, of Course, Russia:' Putin Ally". Newsweek. 4 March 2024.
  170. ^ "Zelenskyy dismisses Pope Francis's call for Ukraine to negotiate peace with Russia". Sky News. 10 March 2024.
  171. ^ a b "Germany: Putin's peace talk offer with Ukraine 'not serious'". Anadolu Agency. 13 March 2024.
  172. ^ "International talks held in Copenhagen were "constructive," Ukrainian president's chief of staff says". 25 June 2023.
  173. ^ Andrew Gray (26 June 2023). "Ukraine 'peace summit' talks make progress but long way to go, officials say". www.reuters.com. Retrieved 18 February 2024.
  174. ^ "Political advisors from 15 countries discuss Ukraine Peace Formula in Copenhagen. Espreso". global.espreso.tv.
  175. ^ O'Carroll, Lisa (6 August 2023). "China 'backs further Ukraine peace talks' after Saudi Arabia summit". The Guardian.
  176. ^ "Ukraine Recap: Malta Meeting Aims to Advance Peace Formula - BNN Bloomberg". 28 October 2023.
  177. ^ "Malta hosts two-day Ukraine peace formula talks". 29 October 2023.
  178. ^ "Ukraine holds peace formula talks in Malta, but Russia is absent". 28 October 2023.
  179. ^ "More countries join talks on Ukraine peace formula, but not China". 15 January 2024.
  180. ^ "Over 80 Delegations to Discuss Ukraine's Peace Formula in Davos Meeting". 12 January 2024.
  181. ^ "China talks 'peace,' woos Europe and trashes Biden in Munich". 18 February 2023.
  182. ^ "Chinese peace proposal on Ukraine provokes western scepticism". Financial Times. 18 February 2023.
  183. ^ Nichols, Michelle (23 February 2023). "One year into Ukraine war, China says sending weapons will not bring peace". Reuters.
  184. ^ Wintour, Patrick (23 February 2023). "Germany and China clash over west's supply of weapons to Ukraine". The Guardian.
  185. ^ Davidson, Helen; Hawkins, Amy (24 February 2023). "Western leaders give cool response to China's plan for Ukraine peace talks". The Guardian.
  186. ^ "China's Position on the Political Settlement of the Ukraine Crisis". www.fmprc.gov.cn. 24 February 2023. Retrieved 7 March 2023.
  187. ^ "Ukraine's Zelensky says he plans to meet China's Xi". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 25 February 2023.
  188. ^ "Russia welcomes China peace plan, says it is open to talks". Reuters. 24 February 2023. Retrieved 25 February 2023.
  189. ^ "Kremlin, on China Plan, Says No Conditions for Peace 'At the Moment' in Ukraine". The Moscow Times. 27 February 2023.
  190. ^ "China says Ukraine crisis driven by 'invisible hand'". www.reuters.com. 7 March 2023. Retrieved 6 March 2023.
  191. ^ Uras, Umut; Mohamed, Edna; Hatuqa, Dalia (20 March 2023). "China's Xi arrives in Russia for state visit as Ukraine war rages". Al Jazeera. Archived from the original on 21 March 2023.
  192. ^ "Putin welcomes China's controversial proposals for peace in Ukraine". The Guardian. 21 March 2023.
  193. ^ "China's Xi calls Ukraine's Zelenskyy, after weeks of intensifying pressure to do so". National Public Radio. 26 April 2023.
  194. ^ "With Zelensky call, Xi Jinping steps up bid to broker peace – but does he have a plan?". CNN. 27 April 2023.
  195. ^ "Europe Rebuffs China's Efforts to Split the West in Pushing Ukraine Cease-Fire". The Wall Street Journal. 26 May 2023.
  196. ^ Pancevski, Bojan; Mackrael, Kim (26 May 2023). "Europe Rebuffs China's Efforts to Split the West in Pushing Ukraine Cease-Fire". The Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 27 May 2023.
  197. ^ "Ukraine, Russia agree to export grain, ending a standoff that threatened food supply". www.npr.org. 22 July 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  198. ^ "Russia strikes Ukraine's Black Sea port of Odesa hours after grain deals signed". www.npr.org. 23 July 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  199. ^ "'He simply cannot be trusted:' World leaders slam Putin's attack on Odesa following sea corridor deal". CNBC. 23 July 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  200. ^ "First shipment of Ukraine grain leaves Odessa under Türkiye-brokered deal". TRT World. 1 August 2022. Retrieved 2 August 2022.
  201. ^ "Most Ukrainians rule out any territorial concessions to end war". Bloomberg. 24 May 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  202. ^ "Nearly 90% of Ukrainians oppose territorial concessions to Russia - poll". Euronews. 16 September 2022. Retrieved 16 October 2022.
  203. ^ "Poll: Majority Of Ukrainians Support Continued Fighting". Forbes. 18 October 2022.
  204. ^ "Make peace, not war". Meduza. 30 November 2022.
  205. ^ "Germany's Scholz, Instrumental in Securing U.S. Tanks for Ukraine, Emerges With Little Credit". The Wall Street Journal. 27 January 2023.
  206. ^ "One year on: European and American attitudes to the war in Ukraine". YouGov. 24 February 2023. Retrieved 25 February 2024.
  207. ^ "US public support declines for arming Ukraine, Reuters/Ipsos poll shows". Reuters. 5 October 2023. Retrieved 6 October 2023.