What do you think?
Rate this book
Sons of Sinclair #3
Highland Justice
Without mercy, there is no love in this third installment of the Sons of Sinclair historical romance series by award-winning author Heather McCollum.
Gideon Sinclair, the third Sinclair brother, judges everything in stark terms of good and evil. There is nothing in between, and he is efficient at passing judgment without mercy. Now that his clan has conquered the warring Mackays, Gideon starts the process of integrating them into the Sinclair Clan. He will sort the people, punish the bad, and better the lives of the good. Judging is as easy to him as breathing, until he meets Cait Mackay, who steals his breath...along with his Sinclair ring.
A young widow, Cait Mackay has given her life over to helping the orphaned children in the clan. But love won’t put shoes on their cold feet and food in their stomachs. Cait tired years ago of seeing the rich get richer and the poor suffer more and more, so she decided to do something about it. An agile thief of the rich by night, when she is caught, the new conquering chief must decide her fate.
When Gideon realizes that the thief is the same woman who had already captured his attention, he hesitates for the first time in his life. Letting her get away with her deed leads to more trouble when she is accused of stealing from King James and is arrested. Now Gideon must commit his own crime against the Scottish crown if he is to save Cait. But can a man who was raised to honor and uphold justice break the law for the woman who’s stolen his heart?
Gideon Sinclair, the third Sinclair brother, judges everything in stark terms of good and evil. There is nothing in between, and he is efficient at passing judgment without mercy. Now that his clan has conquered the warring Mackays, Gideon starts the process of integrating them into the Sinclair Clan. He will sort the people, punish the bad, and better the lives of the good. Judging is as easy to him as breathing, until he meets Cait Mackay, who steals his breath...along with his Sinclair ring.
A young widow, Cait Mackay has given her life over to helping the orphaned children in the clan. But love won’t put shoes on their cold feet and food in their stomachs. Cait tired years ago of seeing the rich get richer and the poor suffer more and more, so she decided to do something about it. An agile thief of the rich by night, when she is caught, the new conquering chief must decide her fate.
When Gideon realizes that the thief is the same woman who had already captured his attention, he hesitates for the first time in his life. Letting her get away with her deed leads to more trouble when she is accused of stealing from King James and is arrested. Now Gideon must commit his own crime against the Scottish crown if he is to save Cait. But can a man who was raised to honor and uphold justice break the law for the woman who’s stolen his heart?
402 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published April 26, 2022
About the author
Heather McCollum
49 books944 followersI am Heather McCollum, writer of 16th and 17th century Scottish romance full of adventure and intrigue, sprinkled with humor, history, and spice. Brawny Highlanders and feisty heroines are my favorite characters!
I am also a mom of three kids, dog-mom of one rescued geriatric golden retriever, and wife of one 6 foot 4 inch Highlander. When I’m not trying to help my kids make it through the day, baking things I see on The Great British Baking Show, or writing, I’m usually educating women on ovarian cancer (I’m a nine-year survivor).
I love kilted heroes, chai lattes, and eating buttered air-popped popcorn for dinner on Friday nights (my dog loves this one too).
If you’re interested in my new releases, fun historical tidbits, sales, and giveaways, sign up for my newsletter!
Newsletter https://www.heathermccollum.com/newsl...
And you are welcome to stalk me here as well:
Twitter https://twitter.com/HMcCollumAuthor
FB https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMcCol...
Pinterest http://www.pinterest.com/hmccollumaut...
I am also a mom of three kids, dog-mom of one rescued geriatric golden retriever, and wife of one 6 foot 4 inch Highlander. When I’m not trying to help my kids make it through the day, baking things I see on The Great British Baking Show, or writing, I’m usually educating women on ovarian cancer (I’m a nine-year survivor).
I love kilted heroes, chai lattes, and eating buttered air-popped popcorn for dinner on Friday nights (my dog loves this one too).
If you’re interested in my new releases, fun historical tidbits, sales, and giveaways, sign up for my newsletter!
Newsletter https://www.heathermccollum.com/newsl...
And you are welcome to stalk me here as well:
Twitter https://twitter.com/HMcCollumAuthor
FB https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMcCol...
Pinterest http://www.pinterest.com/hmccollumaut...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews
March 14, 2022
Thank you NetGalley and Entangled Publishing, LLC for this arc.
I have not read this author before now but was encouraged by the high ratings of the previous 2 books of this series. And maybe I should have backed up and read those before reading this 3rd book.... as I was disappointed with this one.
Gideon, the "Horseman of Justice" fell into insta-love with Cait....
Oh c'mon folks... He was such a rigid stick trying desperately to stick to and live up to his crazy dead father's expectations for himself / his brothers as a "Horseman".
And then there's Cait... Who'd been so abused (mentally and physically) by her dead husband the village left her alone to take in orphaned children, while the village steward tried to lure her into bed with himself. And punishing her for her refusal by withholding chickens he'd been ordered to distribute to the villagers and not fixing her roof.
One evening, she's out with the children playing hide and seek The kids are hiding while she's "twirling about" in a field with snow falling about her when Gideon spots her riding to his new castle. Oops! One of the kids falls into a frozen river trying to hide and rest start squawking interrupting this "magical vision" and Gideon runs off to rescue Willa and carries her home on his horse with the rest of them.
While in Cait's run-down and dinky cottage, Cait takes the opportunity to pick his pocket all the while worrying about her half frozen sister.
And so the story begins...
I read it to the end. I have to admit I laughed at all the plot contrivances. And there were a LOT of them. A king making a visit, too many political machinations to keep up with, charges of treason against most everyone, Cait's not s0 "secret" violent and obsessed admirer yadda, yadda, yadda.
It was a romance, Gideon found some flexibility by the end while Cait found sexual gratification. All's well that ends well.
2.0 stars
I have not read this author before now but was encouraged by the high ratings of the previous 2 books of this series. And maybe I should have backed up and read those before reading this 3rd book.... as I was disappointed with this one.
Gideon, the "Horseman of Justice" fell into insta-love with Cait....
Oh c'mon folks... He was such a rigid stick trying desperately to stick to and live up to his crazy dead father's expectations for himself / his brothers as a "Horseman".
And then there's Cait... Who'd been so abused (mentally and physically) by her dead husband the village left her alone to take in orphaned children, while the village steward tried to lure her into bed with himself. And punishing her for her refusal by withholding chickens he'd been ordered to distribute to the villagers and not fixing her roof.
One evening, she's out with the children playing hide and seek The kids are hiding while she's "twirling about" in a field with snow falling about her when Gideon spots her riding to his new castle. Oops! One of the kids falls into a frozen river trying to hide and rest start squawking interrupting this "magical vision" and Gideon runs off to rescue Willa and carries her home on his horse with the rest of them.
While in Cait's run-down and dinky cottage, Cait takes the opportunity to pick his pocket all the while worrying about her half frozen sister.
And so the story begins...
I read it to the end. I have to admit I laughed at all the plot contrivances. And there were a LOT of them. A king making a visit, too many political machinations to keep up with, charges of treason against most everyone, Cait's not s0 "secret" violent and obsessed admirer yadda, yadda, yadda.
It was a romance, Gideon found some flexibility by the end while Cait found sexual gratification. All's well that ends well.
2.0 stars
December 24, 2022
I have been waiting for this story for about a year, ever since I finished book two of the series 🙃 Let me tell ya, Heather McCollum has written another exceptional story! I loved everything about the story, Gideon & Cait are wonderful together.
Gideon was raised by a raving mad father who was convinced his four sons were the 4 Horseman of the Apocalypse. Each son had his role drilled into him from the moment the lad could walk, for Gideon his role was to provide justice--he deciphered wrong doings, plotting, threats to The Sinclair Clan--if he found a person guilty, he then decided the punishment. So he was the law - investigator, banister, jury. and judge - his judgment was never ignored or questioned.
Then he became Chieftain of the Mackay Clan and his world suddenly went from black & white, right & wrong, good versus evil, and the justified versus the unjustified...to a world full of emotion & decisions made under the influence of love. Basically, his neat orderly world was suddenly very chaotic, and there was one Lass at the center of the chaos - Caitlin Gunn Mackay.
Cait is a strong, determined and protective woman. Previously married to a man who did not treat her well, once widowed Cait began taking in orphaned or abandoned children. Cait raised these kids on her own and there was nothing she wouldn't do to help them survive. Its that fierce determination and a mistaken plunder that lead her to Gideon's chamber one night.
The spark between Gideon & Cait leads to a kiss neither of them can forget. That first taste of Cait has Gideon longing for more...but first he has a thief to punish. It just so happens the lass he craves & the thief are one and the same. 🤨
Let me tell ya this book has it all -- two MCs that have spectacular chemistry, the return of characters from previous books, secondary/supporting characters that add extra layers to the plot, hot as hell bedroom action (broken bed anyone?), some small scrimmages where the Sinclair's show their strength, a woman who learns to trust a man with her heart, and a man strong enough to fall in love!!
Perfection!! ❤
Now the wait begins for the next book of the series and I have a feeling that the youngest of the 4 Sinclair brothers, The Horseman of Death, is going to tear our hearts out with his story. 😢
I HIGHLY recommend this book & the entire series, if you enjoy medieval highlander romance-- you will love this series ❤
5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | 5 Flames 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 | 2022 Top Book 🏆🏆
Gideon was raised by a raving mad father who was convinced his four sons were the 4 Horseman of the Apocalypse. Each son had his role drilled into him from the moment the lad could walk, for Gideon his role was to provide justice--he deciphered wrong doings, plotting, threats to The Sinclair Clan--if he found a person guilty, he then decided the punishment. So he was the law - investigator, banister, jury. and judge - his judgment was never ignored or questioned.
Then he became Chieftain of the Mackay Clan and his world suddenly went from black & white, right & wrong, good versus evil, and the justified versus the unjustified...to a world full of emotion & decisions made under the influence of love. Basically, his neat orderly world was suddenly very chaotic, and there was one Lass at the center of the chaos - Caitlin Gunn Mackay.
Cait is a strong, determined and protective woman. Previously married to a man who did not treat her well, once widowed Cait began taking in orphaned or abandoned children. Cait raised these kids on her own and there was nothing she wouldn't do to help them survive. Its that fierce determination and a mistaken plunder that lead her to Gideon's chamber one night.
The spark between Gideon & Cait leads to a kiss neither of them can forget. That first taste of Cait has Gideon longing for more...but first he has a thief to punish. It just so happens the lass he craves & the thief are one and the same. 🤨
Let me tell ya this book has it all -- two MCs that have spectacular chemistry, the return of characters from previous books, secondary/supporting characters that add extra layers to the plot, hot as hell bedroom action (broken bed anyone?), some small scrimmages where the Sinclair's show their strength, a woman who learns to trust a man with her heart, and a man strong enough to fall in love!!
Perfection!! ❤
Now the wait begins for the next book of the series and I have a feeling that the youngest of the 4 Sinclair brothers, The Horseman of Death, is going to tear our hearts out with his story. 😢
I HIGHLY recommend this book & the entire series, if you enjoy medieval highlander romance-- you will love this series ❤
5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | 5 Flames 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 | 2022 Top Book 🏆🏆
April 29, 2022
Barbara’s rating: 4.25 of 5 Stars
Series: Sons of Sinclair #3
Publication Date: 4/26/22
Period: Elizabethan - Scotland
Number of Pages: 400
Well! What a happy little accident this was. When I requested this book, it was because I THOUGHT I had read the first two. Turns out I had not. So, I can truthfully tell you that you can easily read and follow this book without having read the others. I can also tell you that this book seems to have something for everyone – steamy romance, traitors, a bit of humor, a strait-laced unsmiling hero who learns what love and justice really are, a delightful heroine who has a highly unique talent as well as a heart as big as the Highlands, vile villains, and biblical wrath (as in the 4 Horsemen of the Apocalypse). I loved the story, but I thought the 4 Horsemen part was a bit . . . well, maybe silly isn’t the right word, but I find it a bit hard to buy four strong, intelligent men who buy into that no matter how they were raised. Anyway – that didn’t keep me from loving the story.
Gideon Sinclair is the third brother and the third Horseman of the Apocalypse. He is the Horseman of Justice. For him, everything is either good or evil – there is no middle ground. His judgment is swift and definitely not merciful. The Sinclairs have vanquished the MacKay clan and with their secret alliances with other clans around them, they are the strongest clan in Scotland. If they were not loyal to King James, they could easily defeat the Stuart and rule Scotland themselves.
It is Gideon’s assignment to assimilate the MacKay clan into the Sinclair clan, but he’s not having a lot of luck doing it. The people cower from him and do their best to avoid him. Why? He has been very benevolent – he’s ordered they be given food, clothing, even shillings – why do they look at him in fear? When a wee slip of a young woman boldly begins to show him the error of his ways, can he bend enough to begin to see things from the people’s point of view?
At only fifteen years of age, Cait Gunn MacKay was sold into an abusive marriage by her greedy uncle. Cait endured several years of torture and abuse at the hands of her husband before he, thankfully, died. Since then, she’s encouraged everyone to think of her as the Ice Queen so none of the men will approach her. She never wants anything to do with any man again. She does, however, wish she had children of her own. Even though she has little enough for herself, she has begun taking in lost and abandoned children and raising them. She’ll do whatever she has to do to keep those children safe, fed, clothed, and loved. She’ll even steal from the man who just helped rescue her sister.
Gideon must sit in judgment of Cait and it just doesn’t sit well with him – and he shocks everyone – including himself – when he is lenient with her. Ah – do we have the beginning of the Ice Queen melting and the Horsman of Justice beginning to see shades of gray?
This was a wonderful read. The writing was excellent, the plotting and timing were perfect, and some of the villains might surprise you. I can definitely recommend the book. OH! And lest I forget – be sure to read the author's notes about the laws that are at the beginning of each chapter. They are REAL. It sort of made me wonder what some historian a thousand years from now will think of some of our laws.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Series: Sons of Sinclair #3
Publication Date: 4/26/22
Period: Elizabethan - Scotland
Number of Pages: 400
Well! What a happy little accident this was. When I requested this book, it was because I THOUGHT I had read the first two. Turns out I had not. So, I can truthfully tell you that you can easily read and follow this book without having read the others. I can also tell you that this book seems to have something for everyone – steamy romance, traitors, a bit of humor, a strait-laced unsmiling hero who learns what love and justice really are, a delightful heroine who has a highly unique talent as well as a heart as big as the Highlands, vile villains, and biblical wrath (as in the 4 Horsemen of the Apocalypse). I loved the story, but I thought the 4 Horsemen part was a bit . . . well, maybe silly isn’t the right word, but I find it a bit hard to buy four strong, intelligent men who buy into that no matter how they were raised. Anyway – that didn’t keep me from loving the story.
Gideon Sinclair is the third brother and the third Horseman of the Apocalypse. He is the Horseman of Justice. For him, everything is either good or evil – there is no middle ground. His judgment is swift and definitely not merciful. The Sinclairs have vanquished the MacKay clan and with their secret alliances with other clans around them, they are the strongest clan in Scotland. If they were not loyal to King James, they could easily defeat the Stuart and rule Scotland themselves.
It is Gideon’s assignment to assimilate the MacKay clan into the Sinclair clan, but he’s not having a lot of luck doing it. The people cower from him and do their best to avoid him. Why? He has been very benevolent – he’s ordered they be given food, clothing, even shillings – why do they look at him in fear? When a wee slip of a young woman boldly begins to show him the error of his ways, can he bend enough to begin to see things from the people’s point of view?
At only fifteen years of age, Cait Gunn MacKay was sold into an abusive marriage by her greedy uncle. Cait endured several years of torture and abuse at the hands of her husband before he, thankfully, died. Since then, she’s encouraged everyone to think of her as the Ice Queen so none of the men will approach her. She never wants anything to do with any man again. She does, however, wish she had children of her own. Even though she has little enough for herself, she has begun taking in lost and abandoned children and raising them. She’ll do whatever she has to do to keep those children safe, fed, clothed, and loved. She’ll even steal from the man who just helped rescue her sister.
Gideon must sit in judgment of Cait and it just doesn’t sit well with him – and he shocks everyone – including himself – when he is lenient with her. Ah – do we have the beginning of the Ice Queen melting and the Horsman of Justice beginning to see shades of gray?
This was a wonderful read. The writing was excellent, the plotting and timing were perfect, and some of the villains might surprise you. I can definitely recommend the book. OH! And lest I forget – be sure to read the author's notes about the laws that are at the beginning of each chapter. They are REAL. It sort of made me wonder what some historian a thousand years from now will think of some of our laws.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
April 28, 2022
Sinclair synchronicity!
All the right requirements here for a scintillating Highlands Historical Romance. 1550 Northern Coastlands o a Scotland. Brawny brother of the Sinclair highland chieftain, Gideon Sinclair, is one of four brothers, all trained by an unforgiving, maddened father, to be the Scottish equivalent of the four Horseman of the Apocalypse. Gideon is Justice. As their Aunt Merida tells them, ‘“You we’re all raised engulfed in his madness.”’
Only when Gideon’s unyielding exterior meets a fierce, feisty woman is he softened, and softened, and softened then some. And with the orphans Gideon fosters his heart slips a little more into buttery whimsey.
Mind you Cait Mackay is no pushover, and the many talents she has are eye watering. I’m not even going to mention the fate of the bed! (Oops, I just did!)
Oh! And these two might have to contend with King James, with treason and murder, and finding love. Enemy into Lover and Marriage of Convenience trope blends to make a satisfying and intriguing tale.
An Entangled ARC via NetGalley
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
All the right requirements here for a scintillating Highlands Historical Romance. 1550 Northern Coastlands o a Scotland. Brawny brother of the Sinclair highland chieftain, Gideon Sinclair, is one of four brothers, all trained by an unforgiving, maddened father, to be the Scottish equivalent of the four Horseman of the Apocalypse. Gideon is Justice. As their Aunt Merida tells them, ‘“You we’re all raised engulfed in his madness.”’
Only when Gideon’s unyielding exterior meets a fierce, feisty woman is he softened, and softened, and softened then some. And with the orphans Gideon fosters his heart slips a little more into buttery whimsey.
Mind you Cait Mackay is no pushover, and the many talents she has are eye watering. I’m not even going to mention the fate of the bed! (Oops, I just did!)
Oh! And these two might have to contend with King James, with treason and murder, and finding love. Enemy into Lover and Marriage of Convenience trope blends to make a satisfying and intriguing tale.
An Entangled ARC via NetGalley
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
April 28, 2022
Raised on books and tangible knowledge, Gideon Sinclair has always embraced his role as dispenser of justice for his clan. He sees things in terms of right and wrong with no room for deviation in between. His prowess at cultivating allies has led to his role as master of Varrich Castle, working to integrate the violence-prone MacKay clan with the Sinclairs. He’s working to make improvements and dole out punishments where necessary and one of his first judgments is of Cait MacKay, a young widow to whom he's instantly attracted, and who stole a valuable ring from him.
Cait MacKay spends her time caring for the clan’s orphans but with the poor conditions they’ve faced in the past few years that has often meant stealing to keep them fed and clothed. She’s been stealing to help others in the clan as well, but when she’s caught, she must suffer Gideon’s punishment.
Upon learning Cait’s identity, Gideon finds himself hesitant to punish someone for the first time in his life. He knows he can’t let her get away with it completely, but comes up with a light punishment, only to have her land in even more trouble when King James comes for a surprise Hogmanay visit, suspicious of treason everywhere. Gideon is faced with the impossible choice of following his heart by breaking the law or adhering to it and seeing his love come to harm.
I’ll admit, I didn’t care much for Gideon or Cait at first, but I don’t think I was supposed to. To begin with Gideon is stern, rigid, unyielding in his beliefs that right versus wrong is an immutable fact with no gray areas. He acts only on facts with little thought for the feelings or emotions of others. Meanwhile, Cait acted with perhaps too much emotion, without giving much thought to potential consequences. These two had much to learn about themselves and the things they valued in life and in that respect, they brought out the best in each other. Cait had to learn to trust someone else to look out for her best interests, something that was very difficult for her after having been forced to be independent for a long time. Gideon had to learn to compromise and see the world through a less judgmental veil. They were both the better for having met one another and I enjoyed the side characters and the dose of intrigue in the plot, even if it was a bit more angst than I had expected. All in all, I enjoyed the pacing of this story and Gideon’s standing up for what was right, even when that meant changing up his own views and standing against his king to follow his heart. I will be looking forward to Bas’ story now.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own. Blog link: https://mustreadalltheromance.blogspo...
Cait MacKay spends her time caring for the clan’s orphans but with the poor conditions they’ve faced in the past few years that has often meant stealing to keep them fed and clothed. She’s been stealing to help others in the clan as well, but when she’s caught, she must suffer Gideon’s punishment.
Upon learning Cait’s identity, Gideon finds himself hesitant to punish someone for the first time in his life. He knows he can’t let her get away with it completely, but comes up with a light punishment, only to have her land in even more trouble when King James comes for a surprise Hogmanay visit, suspicious of treason everywhere. Gideon is faced with the impossible choice of following his heart by breaking the law or adhering to it and seeing his love come to harm.
I’ll admit, I didn’t care much for Gideon or Cait at first, but I don’t think I was supposed to. To begin with Gideon is stern, rigid, unyielding in his beliefs that right versus wrong is an immutable fact with no gray areas. He acts only on facts with little thought for the feelings or emotions of others. Meanwhile, Cait acted with perhaps too much emotion, without giving much thought to potential consequences. These two had much to learn about themselves and the things they valued in life and in that respect, they brought out the best in each other. Cait had to learn to trust someone else to look out for her best interests, something that was very difficult for her after having been forced to be independent for a long time. Gideon had to learn to compromise and see the world through a less judgmental veil. They were both the better for having met one another and I enjoyed the side characters and the dose of intrigue in the plot, even if it was a bit more angst than I had expected. All in all, I enjoyed the pacing of this story and Gideon’s standing up for what was right, even when that meant changing up his own views and standing against his king to follow his heart. I will be looking forward to Bas’ story now.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own. Blog link: https://mustreadalltheromance.blogspo...
April 13, 2022
Maybe 4.5 stars
Gideon Sinclair, the third son of George Sinclair and known as the Horseman of Justice is returning to Varrich Castle when he comes upon a woman twirling in the falling snow. He approaches and she tries to cover up what she is doing, but when one of her children screams for help – they both follow the sound and Gideon saves a much younger woman from drowning. He insists on taking her home.
Widow Cait Gunn Mckay is terrified that her sister Willa might take ill and die, so much so that she decides to steal some coin from their rescuer, but soon realizes that she stole his ring as well – a ring proclaiming him to be the Horseman of Justice. Worried that he will discover the theft and come for her – leaving her adopted children defenseless. She uses her skills to enter his rooms to return the ill-gotten goods and is caught. But a bone-melting kiss enables her to escape out his window. But Gideon is on to the Orphan’s home matron. He catches her and is ready to pass judgment – but to his shock, the villagers rally around her and make Gideon begin to rethink not only her punishment but his calling.
He is merciful with her and they form a friendship, which quickly becomes more and has Gideon wondering if things are not as black and white as he always assumed. HEA begins to look like a possibility, but when the king arrives and whispers of treason abound, Gideon will have to choose between the woman he has come to love and the king he has sworn to serve.
This third book in the series is an adventure, filled with memorable characters, steamy love scenes, great secondary characters, cameos from the other “Horsemen”, lots of villains, a heroine with a unique talent and a big heart, a hero who learns the real meaning of justice, lots of action and a few laughs to keep the book from being too intense. I did think the book started slow and was a little repetitious with the “Horsemen” references, but once Gideon and Cait meet, things get interesting and the pace picks up. This is the third book in the series and could be read as a standalone, but I would recommend reading the series in order. Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I am happy to recommend this title.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that I requested and was provided to me by the publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.*
Gideon Sinclair, the third son of George Sinclair and known as the Horseman of Justice is returning to Varrich Castle when he comes upon a woman twirling in the falling snow. He approaches and she tries to cover up what she is doing, but when one of her children screams for help – they both follow the sound and Gideon saves a much younger woman from drowning. He insists on taking her home.
Widow Cait Gunn Mckay is terrified that her sister Willa might take ill and die, so much so that she decides to steal some coin from their rescuer, but soon realizes that she stole his ring as well – a ring proclaiming him to be the Horseman of Justice. Worried that he will discover the theft and come for her – leaving her adopted children defenseless. She uses her skills to enter his rooms to return the ill-gotten goods and is caught. But a bone-melting kiss enables her to escape out his window. But Gideon is on to the Orphan’s home matron. He catches her and is ready to pass judgment – but to his shock, the villagers rally around her and make Gideon begin to rethink not only her punishment but his calling.
He is merciful with her and they form a friendship, which quickly becomes more and has Gideon wondering if things are not as black and white as he always assumed. HEA begins to look like a possibility, but when the king arrives and whispers of treason abound, Gideon will have to choose between the woman he has come to love and the king he has sworn to serve.
This third book in the series is an adventure, filled with memorable characters, steamy love scenes, great secondary characters, cameos from the other “Horsemen”, lots of villains, a heroine with a unique talent and a big heart, a hero who learns the real meaning of justice, lots of action and a few laughs to keep the book from being too intense. I did think the book started slow and was a little repetitious with the “Horsemen” references, but once Gideon and Cait meet, things get interesting and the pace picks up. This is the third book in the series and could be read as a standalone, but I would recommend reading the series in order. Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I am happy to recommend this title.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that I requested and was provided to me by the publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.*
May 2, 2022
5 big stars! I really like reading Heather McCollum’s series. She is one of my favorites for current highlands romance writers. I feel this series and her brothers of Wolf Isle, have a marked a change in writing style and I love it! I’ve liked her former series too, but I’m feeling more connected to the characters and am loving their backstories and depth.
In this book, we have Gideon and Cait, Gideon is the starchy follow the rules type of hero and is turned quite awkward by Cait who pops into his life to show him the grey areas and the weird things like being human and having a heart. I liked how his transformation wasn’t a quick oh forget the rules, I’ll be a puppy dog - no his transformation was small and building and actually stays true to his character until you know he’s had a transformation and then comes more to life.
I’m excited for Bas’ story as well. He has more character development in here too. This can be read stand alone but the context and growth from the previous stories will make this feel a more rewarding book.
In this book, we have Gideon and Cait, Gideon is the starchy follow the rules type of hero and is turned quite awkward by Cait who pops into his life to show him the grey areas and the weird things like being human and having a heart. I liked how his transformation wasn’t a quick oh forget the rules, I’ll be a puppy dog - no his transformation was small and building and actually stays true to his character until you know he’s had a transformation and then comes more to life.
I’m excited for Bas’ story as well. He has more character development in here too. This can be read stand alone but the context and growth from the previous stories will make this feel a more rewarding book.
April 26, 2022
"... there before me was a black horse! It's rider holding a pair of scales in his hand." Revelations 6-5.
Gideon Sinclair was raised by his father as the Horseman of Justice. As the new Chief of Clan Mackay, he strives to keep the peace by using a swift sword for punishment. To him, justice is black and white from the lessons taught by his father, derived from books. Cait Mackay's home is the Orphans' Home. Cheated out of the new clan chief's promise for sources of food, she steals from Gideon, but gets caught when she tries to return it. Gideon comes face to face with a dilemma to save Cait's life. As Cait says, "the good things in life are messy." One man's struggle to give out justice with a compassionate heart and a woman who teaches him about love. Violence and humor.
4 1/2*STARS*
Heat level 3.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.
Gideon Sinclair was raised by his father as the Horseman of Justice. As the new Chief of Clan Mackay, he strives to keep the peace by using a swift sword for punishment. To him, justice is black and white from the lessons taught by his father, derived from books. Cait Mackay's home is the Orphans' Home. Cheated out of the new clan chief's promise for sources of food, she steals from Gideon, but gets caught when she tries to return it. Gideon comes face to face with a dilemma to save Cait's life. As Cait says, "the good things in life are messy." One man's struggle to give out justice with a compassionate heart and a woman who teaches him about love. Violence and humor.
4 1/2*STARS*
Heat level 3.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.
February 25, 2022
Highland Justice is the third book in Heather McCollum’s Sons of Sinclair series, and it is just as entertaining and romantic as the first two. I am really enjoying this series and find each brothers’ story unique and compelling. Even though they were raised to be the four horseman, a unit each with their own roles, the brothers are very different, and they each go on very different journeys. They are all strong alpha males, and Gideon is no exception.
Gideon, the horseman of justice, has strong morals and an unbreakable sense of right and wrong. He is a rule follower, who sees everything in black and white, and he demands the same from others. I like that his return to integrate his clan and the McKay’s and meeting Cait helps Gideon see that there are sometimes shades of grey. Gideon is a man of duty and honor, and he lives by the rules his father instilled, but he begins to question his father’s dictates.
Cait (love her!) helps Gideon realize that there are sometimes extenuating circumstances that should take precedence over his cut-and-dry rules. She teaches him the benefits of mercy and makes him think about the rules as more than an abstract and how they affect everyone. Even though he’s dead, Gideon’s father still controls him, but Cait and her kids soften him and show him that he doesn’t need to be ruled by his deceased father’s unrelenting expectations and demands.
Gideon grows so much throughout the story and really comes into his own. His relationship with Cait, her kids, and other clan members softens him and makes him more approachable, sympathetic, and respected by the clan. Gideon, in turn, helps Cait learn to trust again, especially when it comes to opening her heart to a potential relationship. They have such a fantastic romance, and their journey together as a couple is as compelling as their individual journeys.
As much as I adore Gideon and his brothers, I also loved Cait and her kids! Cait is a survivor, and she is so strong and courageous. Known throughout the clan as being cold, she knows what to do to protect herself and those she loves, and underneath she is a warm, caring, fiercely protective, and compassionate woman. She also has a super cool and unique hobby that’s pretty impressive and comes in handy. The orphans under her care are also wonderful – strong, brave, and loving, this found family is one of my favorite parts of the story. All of the children are fantastic, and they add so much to the story.
Upon his return, Gideon comes to realize that things are not running the way he expected. He also realizes, especially once the king arrives, that there might be traitors in their midst. This adds a lot of suspense and intrigue to the story as they try to figure out who is working for them and who is plotting against them. And for those of you who read the first books in the series, you’ll be excited to know several of the characters have roles in this book too.
Special thanks to NetGalley, Entangled Publishing, and the author for providing me with a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts are my own.
Gideon, the horseman of justice, has strong morals and an unbreakable sense of right and wrong. He is a rule follower, who sees everything in black and white, and he demands the same from others. I like that his return to integrate his clan and the McKay’s and meeting Cait helps Gideon see that there are sometimes shades of grey. Gideon is a man of duty and honor, and he lives by the rules his father instilled, but he begins to question his father’s dictates.
Cait (love her!) helps Gideon realize that there are sometimes extenuating circumstances that should take precedence over his cut-and-dry rules. She teaches him the benefits of mercy and makes him think about the rules as more than an abstract and how they affect everyone. Even though he’s dead, Gideon’s father still controls him, but Cait and her kids soften him and show him that he doesn’t need to be ruled by his deceased father’s unrelenting expectations and demands.
Gideon grows so much throughout the story and really comes into his own. His relationship with Cait, her kids, and other clan members softens him and makes him more approachable, sympathetic, and respected by the clan. Gideon, in turn, helps Cait learn to trust again, especially when it comes to opening her heart to a potential relationship. They have such a fantastic romance, and their journey together as a couple is as compelling as their individual journeys.
As much as I adore Gideon and his brothers, I also loved Cait and her kids! Cait is a survivor, and she is so strong and courageous. Known throughout the clan as being cold, she knows what to do to protect herself and those she loves, and underneath she is a warm, caring, fiercely protective, and compassionate woman. She also has a super cool and unique hobby that’s pretty impressive and comes in handy. The orphans under her care are also wonderful – strong, brave, and loving, this found family is one of my favorite parts of the story. All of the children are fantastic, and they add so much to the story.
Upon his return, Gideon comes to realize that things are not running the way he expected. He also realizes, especially once the king arrives, that there might be traitors in their midst. This adds a lot of suspense and intrigue to the story as they try to figure out who is working for them and who is plotting against them. And for those of you who read the first books in the series, you’ll be excited to know several of the characters have roles in this book too.
Special thanks to NetGalley, Entangled Publishing, and the author for providing me with a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts are my own.
April 26, 2022
Reviewed for
Wit and Sin
The Horseman of Justice learns that not everything is black and white in Highland Justice . Gideon Sinclair was raised to believe things are right or wrong – no in between. He believes in law, order, and has no room for messiness. Cait Mackay knows nothing but messiness and complications; her life is lived in shades of grey. When the two cross paths there’s bound to be an explosion.
Gideon is a good man at his core, but his role in life was so drilled into him by his father that he has a hard time seeing the whole picture. As the new chief of Clan Mackay, he’s doing what he thinks is right to bring peace and wellbeing to his people but it’s clear from the start he’s missing some things. Cait opens his eyes to the messy reality of the world they live in. The survivor of an abusive marriage who now takes in orphans, Cait will do whatever it takes to see her children survive and thrive. She’s strong, smart, and determined – an easy heroine to like. I enjoyed watching her get past Gideon’s walls and to make him question what he’s always known. Gideon, in turn, is someone Cait can rely on. She’s self-sufficient but it’s wonderful that he can be there for her as an equal partner. The two of them just fit and watching them fall for each other was lovely.
Both Gideon and Cait are tested with the arrival of King James. Plots are afoot and both get mixed up in ways that could get them killed. How things work out I’ll leave readers to discover for themselves but suffice it to say that author Heather McCollum gives our protagonists a completely satisfying happily ever after. All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed Highland Justice . Cait and Gideon are both more than others think of them and it was a delight to see them realize it. I am very much looking forward to seeing what McCollum has in store for the youngest Sinclair, Bàs.
FTC Disclosure: I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
The Horseman of Justice learns that not everything is black and white in Highland Justice . Gideon Sinclair was raised to believe things are right or wrong – no in between. He believes in law, order, and has no room for messiness. Cait Mackay knows nothing but messiness and complications; her life is lived in shades of grey. When the two cross paths there’s bound to be an explosion.
Gideon is a good man at his core, but his role in life was so drilled into him by his father that he has a hard time seeing the whole picture. As the new chief of Clan Mackay, he’s doing what he thinks is right to bring peace and wellbeing to his people but it’s clear from the start he’s missing some things. Cait opens his eyes to the messy reality of the world they live in. The survivor of an abusive marriage who now takes in orphans, Cait will do whatever it takes to see her children survive and thrive. She’s strong, smart, and determined – an easy heroine to like. I enjoyed watching her get past Gideon’s walls and to make him question what he’s always known. Gideon, in turn, is someone Cait can rely on. She’s self-sufficient but it’s wonderful that he can be there for her as an equal partner. The two of them just fit and watching them fall for each other was lovely.
Both Gideon and Cait are tested with the arrival of King James. Plots are afoot and both get mixed up in ways that could get them killed. How things work out I’ll leave readers to discover for themselves but suffice it to say that author Heather McCollum gives our protagonists a completely satisfying happily ever after. All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed Highland Justice . Cait and Gideon are both more than others think of them and it was a delight to see them realize it. I am very much looking forward to seeing what McCollum has in store for the youngest Sinclair, Bàs.
FTC Disclosure: I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
April 21, 2022
⚖️ Highland Justice 🎗
Sons of Sinclair Book 3
✒️ Heather McCollum
https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMcCol...
Release Date 04/26/2022
Publisher Entangled Amara
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0951S3H8P/...
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
As the new chief of Clan Mackay, Gideon Sinclair knows the importance of maintaining order at any cost. To keep the conquered clan in line, Gideon must mete out ruthless justice or risk losing their precious new peace. But from the moment he meets Cait Mackay—aye, from the moment the sweetness of her lips captures his—all of Gideon’s careful objectivity is well and thoroughly compromised. Cait knows that kissing the brawny Highlander is a dangerous game. It was bad enough she picked his pocket to feed the children in her care, but sometimes a desperate woman must disguise her crimes any way she can. Only her act of deception has made things worse… Because one kiss with the Highland’s most brutal chief leaves her breathless and out of her depth. Now Gideon must choose between his duty and his heart when his lovely thief is accused of treason against the king himself.
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
Will they find a common path when they each stand at one opposite edge of the road …
I read so many books every year I often have to check when a new one in a series I follows comes out. But every books I have read so far by the author I remember, that in itself proves they all deserve a medal and are worth the read.
So now it is Gideon’s tale, the uncompromising Horseman of Justice, a man who sees like as wrong or right, black and white. He is investigator, attorney, judge and jury to every case presented to him. And while he believes he is fair in his every rendered verdict, there is no in-between or shades of grey for him, he sees in term of guilty, not guilty.
But life is on a mission to teach him quite a lesson of tolerance and acceptance that behind many people’s deeds and errors they are circumstances they would have avoided if they had any other choice.
Cait knows perfectly the wrong of her actions but it is the difference between life and death, she chooses survival. Still when she realizes the man she has stolen from is the renowned Horseman of Judgment, she knows she can not keep her bounty, else she will her recomposed family will suffer. But getting caught, she did not expect.
So the wrath of the man of laws and rules she will face as she dared cross his path, but she won’t go down quietly.
I loved them together, Gideon is one to sentence everyone’s act certain he has all the answers when he lacks the knowledge that led people to the extreme of their actions. He condemns without mercy. Cait will show him not all wrongs are done with evil in mind, most are the result of the need to live one more day. But Cait too will learn from their proximity, to trust outside her close knitted family, to accept she alone can not feed, care for, save, protect her kin.
This is not the action packed story of the previous books, it is more on the slow burn side as while the chemistry between is instantaneous, Gideon has to gain her confidence and trust, he learns to add more shades to his colors scale, to assess all and every facts before making a decision and Cait must have faith in him to do the right thing for her even when she knows it goes against how he has been wired.
5 stars for this wonderful tale of love, trust and resilience.
Bàs’ story is now the next to come, one I have anticipate since the first book in this series. It will be quite a ride.
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen lovemaking scenes
I have been granted an advance copy by the publisher, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://www.instagram.com/tv/Ccmn_cWD...
https://www.facebook.com/429830134272...
#bookstagram #historicalromance #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2022read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #bookquote #romancestagram #readersofinstagram
Sons of Sinclair Book 3
✒️ Heather McCollum
https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMcCol...
Release Date 04/26/2022
Publisher Entangled Amara
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0951S3H8P/...
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
As the new chief of Clan Mackay, Gideon Sinclair knows the importance of maintaining order at any cost. To keep the conquered clan in line, Gideon must mete out ruthless justice or risk losing their precious new peace. But from the moment he meets Cait Mackay—aye, from the moment the sweetness of her lips captures his—all of Gideon’s careful objectivity is well and thoroughly compromised. Cait knows that kissing the brawny Highlander is a dangerous game. It was bad enough she picked his pocket to feed the children in her care, but sometimes a desperate woman must disguise her crimes any way she can. Only her act of deception has made things worse… Because one kiss with the Highland’s most brutal chief leaves her breathless and out of her depth. Now Gideon must choose between his duty and his heart when his lovely thief is accused of treason against the king himself.
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
Will they find a common path when they each stand at one opposite edge of the road …
I read so many books every year I often have to check when a new one in a series I follows comes out. But every books I have read so far by the author I remember, that in itself proves they all deserve a medal and are worth the read.
So now it is Gideon’s tale, the uncompromising Horseman of Justice, a man who sees like as wrong or right, black and white. He is investigator, attorney, judge and jury to every case presented to him. And while he believes he is fair in his every rendered verdict, there is no in-between or shades of grey for him, he sees in term of guilty, not guilty.
But life is on a mission to teach him quite a lesson of tolerance and acceptance that behind many people’s deeds and errors they are circumstances they would have avoided if they had any other choice.
Cait knows perfectly the wrong of her actions but it is the difference between life and death, she chooses survival. Still when she realizes the man she has stolen from is the renowned Horseman of Judgment, she knows she can not keep her bounty, else she will her recomposed family will suffer. But getting caught, she did not expect.
So the wrath of the man of laws and rules she will face as she dared cross his path, but she won’t go down quietly.
I loved them together, Gideon is one to sentence everyone’s act certain he has all the answers when he lacks the knowledge that led people to the extreme of their actions. He condemns without mercy. Cait will show him not all wrongs are done with evil in mind, most are the result of the need to live one more day. But Cait too will learn from their proximity, to trust outside her close knitted family, to accept she alone can not feed, care for, save, protect her kin.
This is not the action packed story of the previous books, it is more on the slow burn side as while the chemistry between is instantaneous, Gideon has to gain her confidence and trust, he learns to add more shades to his colors scale, to assess all and every facts before making a decision and Cait must have faith in him to do the right thing for her even when she knows it goes against how he has been wired.
5 stars for this wonderful tale of love, trust and resilience.
Bàs’ story is now the next to come, one I have anticipate since the first book in this series. It will be quite a ride.
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen lovemaking scenes
I have been granted an advance copy by the publisher, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://www.instagram.com/tv/Ccmn_cWD...
https://www.facebook.com/429830134272...
#bookstagram #historicalromance #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2022read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #bookquote #romancestagram #readersofinstagram
April 28, 2022
Ah, it feels good to be adding another book to my favorites list for 2022! And for it to be a beautiful enemies-to-lovers, grump/sunshine book set in the Scottish Highlands? It's a dream come true. Truly, the only thing that would have made this even more perfect would have been forced proximity...and we even get a taste of that. Heather McCollum has a pleasing way of writing that draws you in, and her characters are so genuine and relatable. I felt so attached to several of them that I felt my heart racing whenever someone was in danger. I didn't want to leave them when the book ended, which is the ultimate sign of a good book, wouldn't you agree?
Gideon Sinclair is the third Horseman of the Sinclair family, raised to be Justice and maintain rule over his people. After conquering the Mackay Clan alongside his brothers, he has moved into Varrich Castle to keep the peace and establish order to the unruly people. They're resistant though, and his methods are without mercy or willingness to bend. When he meets Cait Mackay, she is mesmerizing to him, and after saving her sister from the icy waters of a nearby river, they grow all the closer. But as a young widow caring for the orphaned children of the clan, she is at the mercy of their bellies. They need food, and to get food, they need coin. She steals from him and is caught, and so Justice must be cast upon her. Shockingly, Gideon is moved to show mercy and gives her a lenient sentence that requires her to be in his presence often in the coming weeks as they prepare for the Hogmanay Festival. Things get even more interesting when the King comes to visit, and soon there is more at stake than their budding romance...treason is afoot and Cait is caught in the middle of the plot. Now Gideon must decide if rules are meant to be broken if the breaking protects the one you love.
Gideon is gruff and logical, making him the quintessential grumpy hero with a soft gooey center just waiting to be found. Cait is sunshine with a backbone of steel and the power to bring emotion into the hard heart of Justice. She teaches him to smile more. He gives her super sweet, thoughtful gifts that made my heart melt. The pairing was heavenly. Speaking of Heaven, be aware that there is quite a bit of religious influence in this book, and while it isn't overbearing by any means, it's important to note in case that's not your thing. I found it an interesting play on the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, particularly when you think about how things would be if one of them found humanity when they came to ground. Everyone has a weakness, even a Horseman, if the right person presses the right buttons. Cait found the buttons. All of them. So as time passed, the reader saw Gideon transform from someone with a strict code of morals to seeing things in the shades of grey needed to get through life sane. Poor thing was so wrapped up in his past, when he had a father who wasn't what a young boy needs growing up, that he didn't even realize how much healing he had to do. Cait had her own healing as well, which was beautifully done in the bedroom, might I add. I give the steam an A+. Very nice.
I look forward to reading the next book in the series. Death comes next. But I have a feeling he'll actually learn to live, as his brother did. Exciting times ahead.
**I received a free copy via NetGalley and this is my honest review.**
Gideon Sinclair is the third Horseman of the Sinclair family, raised to be Justice and maintain rule over his people. After conquering the Mackay Clan alongside his brothers, he has moved into Varrich Castle to keep the peace and establish order to the unruly people. They're resistant though, and his methods are without mercy or willingness to bend. When he meets Cait Mackay, she is mesmerizing to him, and after saving her sister from the icy waters of a nearby river, they grow all the closer. But as a young widow caring for the orphaned children of the clan, she is at the mercy of their bellies. They need food, and to get food, they need coin. She steals from him and is caught, and so Justice must be cast upon her. Shockingly, Gideon is moved to show mercy and gives her a lenient sentence that requires her to be in his presence often in the coming weeks as they prepare for the Hogmanay Festival. Things get even more interesting when the King comes to visit, and soon there is more at stake than their budding romance...treason is afoot and Cait is caught in the middle of the plot. Now Gideon must decide if rules are meant to be broken if the breaking protects the one you love.
Gideon is gruff and logical, making him the quintessential grumpy hero with a soft gooey center just waiting to be found. Cait is sunshine with a backbone of steel and the power to bring emotion into the hard heart of Justice. She teaches him to smile more. He gives her super sweet, thoughtful gifts that made my heart melt. The pairing was heavenly. Speaking of Heaven, be aware that there is quite a bit of religious influence in this book, and while it isn't overbearing by any means, it's important to note in case that's not your thing. I found it an interesting play on the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, particularly when you think about how things would be if one of them found humanity when they came to ground. Everyone has a weakness, even a Horseman, if the right person presses the right buttons. Cait found the buttons. All of them. So as time passed, the reader saw Gideon transform from someone with a strict code of morals to seeing things in the shades of grey needed to get through life sane. Poor thing was so wrapped up in his past, when he had a father who wasn't what a young boy needs growing up, that he didn't even realize how much healing he had to do. Cait had her own healing as well, which was beautifully done in the bedroom, might I add. I give the steam an A+. Very nice.
I look forward to reading the next book in the series. Death comes next. But I have a feeling he'll actually learn to live, as his brother did. Exciting times ahead.
**I received a free copy via NetGalley and this is my honest review.**
May 2, 2022
3.5 stars rounded up to 4
You can read all of my reviews at Nerd Girl Loves Books.
This is a fun and flirty historical fiction romance set in 1550 Scotland. This is book 3 of the series, but it is a stand alone story. I haven't read the first 2 books, but there was enough background that I didn't feel like I missed too much. Gideon Sinclair is one of four sons raised by their father to be the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse in their clan. Gideon is Justice and has spent his life learning the law and dispensing justice to the members of his clan.
When Gideon meets young widow Christina MacKay, he's enchanted. She has spent her life helping children that have been orphaned. But she is without means to care for them and occasionally resorts to stealing to put food on the table. When such an incident goes wrong and she finds herself at the mercy of Gideon's justice, he finds himself hesitating at dispensing judgment for the first time in his life. He is lenient with her, but she is eventually accused of stealing from King James and imprisoned. Gideon must decide which is more important, the law or his heart.
This was a fun, quick read. I liked Gideon and Christina and think they made a cute couple. I liked how flirty they were. I also loved that Christina was strong, smart and capable, and that Gideon loved her even more because of these qualities. I thought the whole treason thing with King James was a bit overdone and out of place. It seemed to be included just to create a misunderstanding between Gideon and Christina so they could realize they were in love. This is common in romance books and I get why authors do it, but I still don't like it. Overall, however, this was a minor annoyance and didn't spoil my enjoyment of the book.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and Entangled Publishing, LLC. All opinions are my own.
You can read all of my reviews at Nerd Girl Loves Books.
This is a fun and flirty historical fiction romance set in 1550 Scotland. This is book 3 of the series, but it is a stand alone story. I haven't read the first 2 books, but there was enough background that I didn't feel like I missed too much. Gideon Sinclair is one of four sons raised by their father to be the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse in their clan. Gideon is Justice and has spent his life learning the law and dispensing justice to the members of his clan.
When Gideon meets young widow Christina MacKay, he's enchanted. She has spent her life helping children that have been orphaned. But she is without means to care for them and occasionally resorts to stealing to put food on the table. When such an incident goes wrong and she finds herself at the mercy of Gideon's justice, he finds himself hesitating at dispensing judgment for the first time in his life. He is lenient with her, but she is eventually accused of stealing from King James and imprisoned. Gideon must decide which is more important, the law or his heart.
This was a fun, quick read. I liked Gideon and Christina and think they made a cute couple. I liked how flirty they were. I also loved that Christina was strong, smart and capable, and that Gideon loved her even more because of these qualities. I thought the whole treason thing with King James was a bit overdone and out of place. It seemed to be included just to create a misunderstanding between Gideon and Christina so they could realize they were in love. This is common in romance books and I get why authors do it, but I still don't like it. Overall, however, this was a minor annoyance and didn't spoil my enjoyment of the book.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and Entangled Publishing, LLC. All opinions are my own.
May 9, 2022
I think this is the first book I have read by Heather McCollum and now I feel like I need the first two in the series to obtain the full experience. (And I'm sure the next one in the series is going to be gold)
So, Gideon is a human representation of the biblical Horseman of the Apocalypse, he rules the Sinclair Clan Territory with an iron fist alongside his siblings. He believes that education, diplomacy, and justice are the correct ways to maintain peace and he is quick to deliver judgment. That is until she meets a young widow from the Mckay Clan. She is the caretaker of the village orphans and shows him that not all is as it seems.
Gideon is a little dense in my perspective, cause the dude only thought that the correct way of doing things was his way and the only truth was his truth. As he gets to know, learn and understand Cait, he starts to open his eyes and mind and learn that maybe, just maybe not everything is as he's been taught. He learns empathy and humanity, making him more human and trustworthy to the people under his care.
Cait has kept everyone at arm's length, she has had a hard time with men and the only thing she cares about is taking care, loving, and protecting her kids - they are the village orphans. When she meets Gideon, she doesn't like him and judges him wrong. But as she gets to know Gideon, she finds herself falling for him. And really, it's the small and quiet things Gideon does, the precious gifts, how he listens to her, how he protects her, and how deeply loves her.
5-star read!
✨ 𝓣𝓻𝓸𝓹𝓮𝓼 ✨
Sweet/Gentle Hero/Independent Heroine
Enemies to Lovers
Slow Burn
Grump/Sunshine
*Trigger warning - mention of rape, s*exual assault, and mentions of death.
So, Gideon is a human representation of the biblical Horseman of the Apocalypse, he rules the Sinclair Clan Territory with an iron fist alongside his siblings. He believes that education, diplomacy, and justice are the correct ways to maintain peace and he is quick to deliver judgment. That is until she meets a young widow from the Mckay Clan. She is the caretaker of the village orphans and shows him that not all is as it seems.
Gideon is a little dense in my perspective, cause the dude only thought that the correct way of doing things was his way and the only truth was his truth. As he gets to know, learn and understand Cait, he starts to open his eyes and mind and learn that maybe, just maybe not everything is as he's been taught. He learns empathy and humanity, making him more human and trustworthy to the people under his care.
Cait has kept everyone at arm's length, she has had a hard time with men and the only thing she cares about is taking care, loving, and protecting her kids - they are the village orphans. When she meets Gideon, she doesn't like him and judges him wrong. But as she gets to know Gideon, she finds herself falling for him. And really, it's the small and quiet things Gideon does, the precious gifts, how he listens to her, how he protects her, and how deeply loves her.
5-star read!
✨ 𝓣𝓻𝓸𝓹𝓮𝓼 ✨
Sweet/Gentle Hero/Independent Heroine
Enemies to Lovers
Slow Burn
Grump/Sunshine
*Trigger warning - mention of rape, s*exual assault, and mentions of death.
April 24, 2022
Book three in the Son's of Sinclair series follows Gideon Sinclair, the Horseman of Justice. From the time he was a young boy Gideon was taught by his father to judge the fate of others. Because of this he sees everything in black and white, good or evil and doesn't know how to enjoy life. Now he's leading the Mackay people and most are terrified of his imposing nature.
Cait Mackay is a young widow and caretaker of village orphans. When she and Gideon meet during and emergency involving one the children in her care. Gideon is enchanted with the high spirited Cait and wants her to help him become more likable in the eyes of the Mackay people.
I like that this book shows more lighthearted times with the Sinclair family than the first two books. It was nice seeing the family enjoying festivities. The steam level in the book was also great. Overall I really enjoyed this book and can't wait to read the next one in the series. I've been very interested in learning more about Bas, the youngest Sinclair and am curious about what kind of Lady will win his heart!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Cait Mackay is a young widow and caretaker of village orphans. When she and Gideon meet during and emergency involving one the children in her care. Gideon is enchanted with the high spirited Cait and wants her to help him become more likable in the eyes of the Mackay people.
I like that this book shows more lighthearted times with the Sinclair family than the first two books. It was nice seeing the family enjoying festivities. The steam level in the book was also great. Overall I really enjoyed this book and can't wait to read the next one in the series. I've been very interested in learning more about Bas, the youngest Sinclair and am curious about what kind of Lady will win his heart!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
May 8, 2022
Each book in this series can be read as a standalone book but you will want to read them all. It has been a very long time since I have read a highlander story. After reading this book, my reading appetite has been revived to read more highlander books again. The best part about these types of books it is the witty banter between the two characters.
Gideon and Cait did have some really funny moments between them. Some real zingers. Cait was a good match to Gideon. She could hold her own and go toe to toe with him. I want a Gideon in my life. I mean come on; he broke the bed. He is that strong. Yet, the chemistry Cait and Gideon shared was steamy. If you enjoy reading historical highlander romance books, you will want to pick up a copy of this book.
Gideon and Cait did have some really funny moments between them. Some real zingers. Cait was a good match to Gideon. She could hold her own and go toe to toe with him. I want a Gideon in my life. I mean come on; he broke the bed. He is that strong. Yet, the chemistry Cait and Gideon shared was steamy. If you enjoy reading historical highlander romance books, you will want to pick up a copy of this book.
February 24, 2022
After reading this story I felt that it was more of a soft story, with all the characters being happy and everyone is merry and not just because of the holiday. I loved that the writer grabbed my attention with Gidieon racing to help one of the children. The books entertainment did well with keeping my attention. The dialogue was clear and understanding. The narrative of the story was clear and also understanding. The romance between Gidieon and Cait was very romantic and very heated. The book was an easy read.
February 7, 2022
If ever an author has found the perfect genre that suits her 100%, it's Heather McCollum! Between her style of writing, her imagination and the inexhaustible research, her stories are amazing. The Sons of Sinclair series just keeps getting better and better and I absolutely adored Gideon and Cait's story.
This story made me laugh, cry, sit on the edge of my seat, gasp, swoon, swear at the bad guys and made me want to smack a king! lol One of my most favourite scenes was the nativity play and Trix dropping baby Jesus (a doll!)....priceless!! My heart went out to Gideon, being judge and jury, not an easy thing to do especially when emotions are involved. As for Cait, such a spitfire but I loved how she cared about the children and would do anything to keep them safe.
On a side note, I have a cousin whose daughter is an aerial silk artist and I've had the pleasure of watching her perform a few times. So, in the story when Cait is "flying", I could picture it clearly. So beautiful and graceful!!
I received an ARC of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
This story made me laugh, cry, sit on the edge of my seat, gasp, swoon, swear at the bad guys and made me want to smack a king! lol One of my most favourite scenes was the nativity play and Trix dropping baby Jesus (a doll!)....priceless!! My heart went out to Gideon, being judge and jury, not an easy thing to do especially when emotions are involved. As for Cait, such a spitfire but I loved how she cared about the children and would do anything to keep them safe.
On a side note, I have a cousin whose daughter is an aerial silk artist and I've had the pleasure of watching her perform a few times. So, in the story when Cait is "flying", I could picture it clearly. So beautiful and graceful!!
I received an ARC of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
April 25, 2022
As the new chief of Clan Mackay, Gideon Sinclair knows the importance of maintaining order at any cost, after all he is The Horseman of Justice. But from the moment he meets Cait Mackay all of Gideon’s careful objectivity is well and thoroughly compromised. Cait knows that kissing the brawny Highlander is a dangerous game. It was bad enough she picked his pocket to feed the children in her care.
Gideon is the third Sinclair brother to find love & another well written page turner. I loved Gideon who saw things only in black or white until he met Cait who turned his world upside down. I also loved Cait who would do anything for her 'family'. I found this story built & built until I couldn’t put it down & finally at 3am I finished it. I loved how distrust turned to trust, there was no denying the chemistry between Gideon & Cait & their passion was so hot, she certainly wasn’t an ice maiden, their first bedroom scene ended with a crash!! I can't wait for Bas' story
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
Gideon is the third Sinclair brother to find love & another well written page turner. I loved Gideon who saw things only in black or white until he met Cait who turned his world upside down. I also loved Cait who would do anything for her 'family'. I found this story built & built until I couldn’t put it down & finally at 3am I finished it. I loved how distrust turned to trust, there was no denying the chemistry between Gideon & Cait & their passion was so hot, she certainly wasn’t an ice maiden, their first bedroom scene ended with a crash!! I can't wait for Bas' story
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
April 27, 2022
Scotland
Another phenomenal story by gifted author Heather McCollum, that wraps you in her historical knowledge and transports you to a time and place one can only dream about!
He was the Horseman of Justice, as his father had named him and he took his responsibilities very seriously. Gideon Sinclair, a strong warrior, who punished those who stole or committed crimes.
She was taking care of her sister and several orphans she took in and did her best to protect them. Cait could not believe when the handsome Gideon came to the rescue of her sister, who had fallen in the river! Of course she had to lift a few coins from his pouch to get medicine in case they needed it, but she never expected to also nab his solid gold warrior ring! She had to get it back to him!
Wow such an adventure and I seriously could not put this one down until the end! Oh yes, and wow, what a kiss! (you just need to read to find out!) Love this series!
Another phenomenal story by gifted author Heather McCollum, that wraps you in her historical knowledge and transports you to a time and place one can only dream about!
He was the Horseman of Justice, as his father had named him and he took his responsibilities very seriously. Gideon Sinclair, a strong warrior, who punished those who stole or committed crimes.
She was taking care of her sister and several orphans she took in and did her best to protect them. Cait could not believe when the handsome Gideon came to the rescue of her sister, who had fallen in the river! Of course she had to lift a few coins from his pouch to get medicine in case they needed it, but she never expected to also nab his solid gold warrior ring! She had to get it back to him!
Wow such an adventure and I seriously could not put this one down until the end! Oh yes, and wow, what a kiss! (you just need to read to find out!) Love this series!
December 21, 2022
Unexpectedly funny.
Romance: 2/5
Chemistry: 5/5
1st kiss: +-15% in
Spice: 3/5
Humour: 4/5
Cry factor: 0/5
Suspense: 2/5
Foul Language: 2/5
Positive thoughts:
- This was deliciously funny it was. I loved how the brute Gideon was so obvious of his frightening looks and he tried his best to be gentle and kind to win points with his people and Kate.
- I love a good historical, especially a Scottish one with all the accents. I listen to the audio for this book and the narrator nailed the accents.
- Listening to the audio, I thought the narrator was fabulous, his voice was so gruff and deep, he portrayed our hero well (especially our hero's brother - wow! what a voice!).
- I have to say I loved all the documented information we get in the beginning of the chapters, they really complemented the story well.
Negative thoughts:
- I really didn't like their king, such a snob (but this is purely due to excellent writing).
- There was just one little thing I didn't find credible and that was her surprising talent, but it worked well in the story.
Overall:
- This is a historical, Scottish romance, with wonderful Scottish words and accents.
- It is a fast paced read and will not let you put it down.
- We get strong family love, a sense of justice, suspense and good chemistry with our main characters.
TW: executions
Tropes:
- Historical romance
- Scottish historical
- MMC has a black horse
- Medieval times
- Thief FMC
- Orphaned children
- Strong FMC
- Protector MMC
Romance: 2/5
Chemistry: 5/5
1st kiss: +-15% in
Spice: 3/5
Humour: 4/5
Cry factor: 0/5
Suspense: 2/5
Foul Language: 2/5
Positive thoughts:
- This was deliciously funny it was. I loved how the brute Gideon was so obvious of his frightening looks and he tried his best to be gentle and kind to win points with his people and Kate.
- I love a good historical, especially a Scottish one with all the accents. I listen to the audio for this book and the narrator nailed the accents.
- Listening to the audio, I thought the narrator was fabulous, his voice was so gruff and deep, he portrayed our hero well (especially our hero's brother - wow! what a voice!).
- I have to say I loved all the documented information we get in the beginning of the chapters, they really complemented the story well.
Negative thoughts:
- I really didn't like their king, such a snob (but this is purely due to excellent writing).
- There was just one little thing I didn't find credible and that was her surprising talent, but it worked well in the story.
Overall:
- This is a historical, Scottish romance, with wonderful Scottish words and accents.
- It is a fast paced read and will not let you put it down.
- We get strong family love, a sense of justice, suspense and good chemistry with our main characters.
TW: executions
Tropes:
- Historical romance
- Scottish historical
- MMC has a black horse
- Medieval times
- Thief FMC
- Orphaned children
- Strong FMC
- Protector MMC
April 25, 2022
Highland Justice is Book 3 in the Sons of Sinclair series. It is a series, but can be read as a standalone
I enjoyed the character arc of the hero Gideon Sinclair. We see him gradually transforming from being a rigid rule-follower to letting his heart rule him. Christina, The heroine is a sweet and strong young widow who is very likeable as a character.
The conflict comes when Gideon has to bend his strong sense of justice when Christina is accused of stealing and much more.
This is an enjoyable story full of hunky highlanders, sweet heroines, precocious children, and spirited animals.
I received a complementary copy of this book form the publisher. This is my honest review.
I enjoyed the character arc of the hero Gideon Sinclair. We see him gradually transforming from being a rigid rule-follower to letting his heart rule him. Christina, The heroine is a sweet and strong young widow who is very likeable as a character.
The conflict comes when Gideon has to bend his strong sense of justice when Christina is accused of stealing and much more.
This is an enjoyable story full of hunky highlanders, sweet heroines, precocious children, and spirited animals.
I received a complementary copy of this book form the publisher. This is my honest review.
April 1, 2022
Book: Highland Justice
By Heather McCollum
Series: Sons of Sinclair, Book #3
Publisher: Entangled
Page Length: 330
Release Date: April 26, 2022
Overall Rating: 5/5 stars
Blog Rating: 5 Saltire Flags
The Sons of Sinclair saga continues with the third installment of the Sons of Sinclair.
This story centers around the third Sinclair son, or what the deceased Sinclair Laird George would call his sons, the Horsemen of war. After his wife died in childbirth, with his fourth son, he was filled with grief and became a bit eccentric and insane. He renamed all his sons from the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.
They are figures in the Christian religion, first appearing in the Old Testament's prophetic Book of Zechariah and in the Book of Ezekiel, where they are named as punishments from God, and later in the New Testament's final book, Revelation, an apocalypse written by John of Patmos. Gideon Sinclair is the God of God of equality/ balance why he had a set of scales in his bedchamber. Also know as the Horsemen of Justice.
Now The Sons of Sinclair saga continues with the third installment of the Sons of Sinclair…
Gideon Sinclair saw things as black and white, it was right or it was wrong, it was good or it was evil. There were no in betweens or grey areas or undecided. Now that they had overtaken the battling MacKays he was trying to merge them with Clan Sinclair. He could pass judgement without mercy and that was until he met Cait MacKay. A woman he first meets by saving her drowning younger sister. How does she replay him? By stealing his new gold ring he had just gifted all his siblings for Hogmanay and taking
three shillings which he had caught and must punish the woman he desires for her crimes.
Cait MacKay was a widow and was forced into an unhappy marriage when she was only fifteen summers . Now with an older woman Cait runs an orphans home. Yet they are starving and cold because she refused the MacKay Clan’s Steward’s advances so he wasn’t giving them the food and supplies Gideon had ordered. Yet Cait will do anything to save and protect her children.
Gideon Sinclair did not want the MacKay clan to view him as a monster. Yet he did believe people should be punished for crimes and dishonesty. Soon this woman who dances in the snow, does aerial flying in the trees, making Gideon turns his head like no other. She cares for mistreated forgotten orphans and cares for them like a mother. As she had never been able to conceive which her dead husband reminded her on a daily basis. Yet she would kill, steal or die for her orphaned children.
Cait starts to see this Highlander of Justice in a different light as he tries to help her and her family. Excepts in the middle of the Hogmanay celebration king James visits and someone want to set up someone she cares deeply for as a scapegoat for a treasonous attack! Will Gideon be able to save Cait and those she loves by turning away from his convictions and belief’s. Read and find out!
Another phenomenal story by my go to author Heather McCollum. Another breathtaking story that totally swept me away! I loved so many things in the awe-inspiring magnificent read! It is filled with the brutal reality of children losing parents at such a young age. In this time period and this situation many children would end up on the streets. Luckily this wonderful inspiring heroine with a big warm golden heart found and saved these neglected orphans. Plus she would do anything to protect them even if it meant surrendering herself and putting her life on the line. As for Gideon who had been trained at a young age you are either good or bad. Yet once this woman who had been sold into an unwanted marriage at such a young age opened his heart. Gideon began to understand that maybe there are other possibilities and grey areas. After all we are all only human and sometimes decisions are made under extenuating circumstances.
Yes I absolutely loved this story and it a riveting fast paced, action packed romantic adventure filled with espionage, treason, murder, arrests, imprisonment, betrayal, robbery, honesty, trust, caring, passion love and so much more. I loved this book so much from start to finish and can’t wait to read Bás story next! This is definitely a story not to be missed that I highly recommend!
You can read as a stand alone book but I highly recommend to read every book in this series. I think readers will get a better understanding of the characters and the Sinclair brothers relationship and kinship to each other. Plus their relationship to their sister Hannah too. This book was absolutely phenomenal!
Sons of Sinclair Series
1)Highland Conquest
2)Highland Warrior
3)Highland Justice
Disclaimer: I received an advance reader’s copy from Entangled Publishing. I voluntarily agreed to do an honest, fair review and blog through netgalley. All thoughts, ideas and words are my own.
By Heather McCollum
Series: Sons of Sinclair, Book #3
Publisher: Entangled
Page Length: 330
Release Date: April 26, 2022
Overall Rating: 5/5 stars
Blog Rating: 5 Saltire Flags
The Sons of Sinclair saga continues with the third installment of the Sons of Sinclair.
This story centers around the third Sinclair son, or what the deceased Sinclair Laird George would call his sons, the Horsemen of war. After his wife died in childbirth, with his fourth son, he was filled with grief and became a bit eccentric and insane. He renamed all his sons from the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.
They are figures in the Christian religion, first appearing in the Old Testament's prophetic Book of Zechariah and in the Book of Ezekiel, where they are named as punishments from God, and later in the New Testament's final book, Revelation, an apocalypse written by John of Patmos. Gideon Sinclair is the God of God of equality/ balance why he had a set of scales in his bedchamber. Also know as the Horsemen of Justice.
Now The Sons of Sinclair saga continues with the third installment of the Sons of Sinclair…
Gideon Sinclair saw things as black and white, it was right or it was wrong, it was good or it was evil. There were no in betweens or grey areas or undecided. Now that they had overtaken the battling MacKays he was trying to merge them with Clan Sinclair. He could pass judgement without mercy and that was until he met Cait MacKay. A woman he first meets by saving her drowning younger sister. How does she replay him? By stealing his new gold ring he had just gifted all his siblings for Hogmanay and taking
three shillings which he had caught and must punish the woman he desires for her crimes.
Cait MacKay was a widow and was forced into an unhappy marriage when she was only fifteen summers . Now with an older woman Cait runs an orphans home. Yet they are starving and cold because she refused the MacKay Clan’s Steward’s advances so he wasn’t giving them the food and supplies Gideon had ordered. Yet Cait will do anything to save and protect her children.
Gideon Sinclair did not want the MacKay clan to view him as a monster. Yet he did believe people should be punished for crimes and dishonesty. Soon this woman who dances in the snow, does aerial flying in the trees, making Gideon turns his head like no other. She cares for mistreated forgotten orphans and cares for them like a mother. As she had never been able to conceive which her dead husband reminded her on a daily basis. Yet she would kill, steal or die for her orphaned children.
Cait starts to see this Highlander of Justice in a different light as he tries to help her and her family. Excepts in the middle of the Hogmanay celebration king James visits and someone want to set up someone she cares deeply for as a scapegoat for a treasonous attack! Will Gideon be able to save Cait and those she loves by turning away from his convictions and belief’s. Read and find out!
Another phenomenal story by my go to author Heather McCollum. Another breathtaking story that totally swept me away! I loved so many things in the awe-inspiring magnificent read! It is filled with the brutal reality of children losing parents at such a young age. In this time period and this situation many children would end up on the streets. Luckily this wonderful inspiring heroine with a big warm golden heart found and saved these neglected orphans. Plus she would do anything to protect them even if it meant surrendering herself and putting her life on the line. As for Gideon who had been trained at a young age you are either good or bad. Yet once this woman who had been sold into an unwanted marriage at such a young age opened his heart. Gideon began to understand that maybe there are other possibilities and grey areas. After all we are all only human and sometimes decisions are made under extenuating circumstances.
Yes I absolutely loved this story and it a riveting fast paced, action packed romantic adventure filled with espionage, treason, murder, arrests, imprisonment, betrayal, robbery, honesty, trust, caring, passion love and so much more. I loved this book so much from start to finish and can’t wait to read Bás story next! This is definitely a story not to be missed that I highly recommend!
You can read as a stand alone book but I highly recommend to read every book in this series. I think readers will get a better understanding of the characters and the Sinclair brothers relationship and kinship to each other. Plus their relationship to their sister Hannah too. This book was absolutely phenomenal!
Sons of Sinclair Series
1)Highland Conquest
2)Highland Warrior
3)Highland Justice
Disclaimer: I received an advance reader’s copy from Entangled Publishing. I voluntarily agreed to do an honest, fair review and blog through netgalley. All thoughts, ideas and words are my own.
April 26, 2022
Although not having read the previous two in this series, I still thoroughly enjoyed this book. I love the concept the author has created by bringing the Four Horsemen of Revelations to medieval Scotland. It's so unique and brings such a great touch to the world and the characterizations.
Firstly, the author did such a great job at (re)introducing the characters and their backstories without it becoming overwhelming or creating an info-dump. As someone unfamiliar with the world, it didn't take me very long to catch on for which I was grateful. The hints of the previous events in the series also make me want to go back and read from the beginning. I loved that I was able to immerse in the world so quickly without it becoming a drag.
I loved the characterization! Gideon's struggle with how he was raised and the ideology ingrained in him from his mad father was so interesting to read about. I loved the way he started to open up and see the world from a different perspective because of Cait. Cait's fierceness and determination was such a refreshing part of the book and I loved all of the scenes we were given of her with her children in the Orphan's Home. The romance lacked a bit of chemistry for me but I was overall satisfied with it.
Lastly, the pacing was slow at parts but I immensely enjoyed the ending, especially with all of the twists and treason that occurred. I also really liked how clear and easy it was to picture the battle/fight scenes that appear in the book.
Overall, this book delivered the medieval Scottish Highland romance I was looking for. I love its unique features and the way it's clear that the entire series is intricately woven together while each book still maintains its standalone readability. I can definitely see myself going back to read the previous two and I will be keeping an eye out for the next (and I assume final) book in this series featuring the Horsemen of Death.
Thank you to Entangled Publishing for the ARC!
Firstly, the author did such a great job at (re)introducing the characters and their backstories without it becoming overwhelming or creating an info-dump. As someone unfamiliar with the world, it didn't take me very long to catch on for which I was grateful. The hints of the previous events in the series also make me want to go back and read from the beginning. I loved that I was able to immerse in the world so quickly without it becoming a drag.
I loved the characterization! Gideon's struggle with how he was raised and the ideology ingrained in him from his mad father was so interesting to read about. I loved the way he started to open up and see the world from a different perspective because of Cait. Cait's fierceness and determination was such a refreshing part of the book and I loved all of the scenes we were given of her with her children in the Orphan's Home. The romance lacked a bit of chemistry for me but I was overall satisfied with it.
Lastly, the pacing was slow at parts but I immensely enjoyed the ending, especially with all of the twists and treason that occurred. I also really liked how clear and easy it was to picture the battle/fight scenes that appear in the book.
Overall, this book delivered the medieval Scottish Highland romance I was looking for. I love its unique features and the way it's clear that the entire series is intricately woven together while each book still maintains its standalone readability. I can definitely see myself going back to read the previous two and I will be keeping an eye out for the next (and I assume final) book in this series featuring the Horsemen of Death.
Thank you to Entangled Publishing for the ARC!
April 21, 2022
Trying to find balance between justice and love
Gideon is the most dedicated of the four Sinclair sons, fully dedicated to their roles as the Four Horsemen from the Bible as drilled into them by their now-deceased father. He has had to find his own self-worth through his application of justice, yet when he meets the desperate yet beloved Cait Mackay, he starts to question just who he is and who he has to be.
Cait's life has been anything but just, yet she's become a compassionate, caring leader who runs a small orphanage and will do quite literally anything to provide for her young charges. She demonstrates that wisdom, patience, and mercy are essential to true justice, and she challenges him to do the right thing, regardless of what the rules say.
I loved their slow, sensuous love story, and I actually laughed out loud at the events that relegated the king to the second-best quarters in the castle! I adored the inclusion of historical figures, including King James, and the author's inclusion of quotes from various laws throughout history was elucidating and provided great context for the dilemmas that Gideon faced. I loved the emphasis on learning and the value of books, and welcomed the timely commentary on today's politics.
This is a tremendously satisfying continuation of the Sons of Sinclair series, and I'm looking forward to reading more from this talented author. I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of this book.
Gideon is the most dedicated of the four Sinclair sons, fully dedicated to their roles as the Four Horsemen from the Bible as drilled into them by their now-deceased father. He has had to find his own self-worth through his application of justice, yet when he meets the desperate yet beloved Cait Mackay, he starts to question just who he is and who he has to be.
Cait's life has been anything but just, yet she's become a compassionate, caring leader who runs a small orphanage and will do quite literally anything to provide for her young charges. She demonstrates that wisdom, patience, and mercy are essential to true justice, and she challenges him to do the right thing, regardless of what the rules say.
I loved their slow, sensuous love story, and I actually laughed out loud at the events that relegated the king to the second-best quarters in the castle! I adored the inclusion of historical figures, including King James, and the author's inclusion of quotes from various laws throughout history was elucidating and provided great context for the dilemmas that Gideon faced. I loved the emphasis on learning and the value of books, and welcomed the timely commentary on today's politics.
This is a tremendously satisfying continuation of the Sons of Sinclair series, and I'm looking forward to reading more from this talented author. I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of this book.
February 10, 2022
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own. Thank you Entagled Publishing LLC. and Heather McCollum for providing me with an ARC in exchange for a review.
There's something about a good historical romance that sweeps you away to a different time and place in a way that feels magical and mystical. Whenever I pick up a novel in this genre, I want to feel like I've travelled back in time to an era where strong women defy the social norms that dull their brilliance and fierce, dominant men wear civilty as a thin armour to hide their untamed wildness and warrior personas. I am happy to say that Highland Justice delivers this in spades.
The author does a fantastic job transporting the reader to the wild beauty of the Highlands, where we meet the third Sinclair Brother, also fearfully known as the Horseman of Justice, who is now chief of Clan McKay. Much like his moniker, Gideon has spent his entire life maintaining fairness, order and justice for the good of the Sinclair Clan. However, he meets his match in the soft yet fiercely independent Cait McKay, who believes that beauty is found in the messy, colourful & chaotic things in life, rather than in the rigid, black and white worldview that Gideon favours. Because of a crime Cait committed, she is forced to work for Gideon to pay off her sentence, which causes sparks to fly and delcious banter to be had, and Gideon & Cait realize that perhaps there's more to each other than they first realized.
I loved seeing this couple grow from enemies to lovers - my favourite trope. It was so much fun reading about them clashing heads over their differing worldviews. They certainly knew how to challenge each other, and it made for excellent witty banter. I loved that the author made sure both characters had equally valid points in all their arguments, which made the other pause and reflect. It allowed me to appreciate where Cait & Gideon were coming from without picking sides. It also lent itself beautifully to the progression of their relationship, as both learned to respect, appreciate and value each other for their strengths, thus igniting their romance and passion for each other.
The only reason that I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because I felt that there were so many issues and external obstacles the couple had to overcome on top of the conflict they had with each other. This made it confusing for me to follow at some points, especially as the story progressed and all the subplots were coming to its head. I found that I often had to reread some areas to grasp the nuances of the varying conflicts well. I would have preferred to read about fewer conflicts, but with more page time decidated to fleshing those out for the climax of the plot. Please note that this is ofcourse my own personal preference and other readers may not see this as an issue at all.
Overall, I found Highland Justice to be an excellent read, with brilliant characters, a swoonworthy romance, exciting tension, witty banter, intelligent dialogue and thrilling action scenes. If you're a fan of historical romance with enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity and grumpyxsunshine tropes set in 16th century Scotland, then this is definitely one you do not want to miss.
There's something about a good historical romance that sweeps you away to a different time and place in a way that feels magical and mystical. Whenever I pick up a novel in this genre, I want to feel like I've travelled back in time to an era where strong women defy the social norms that dull their brilliance and fierce, dominant men wear civilty as a thin armour to hide their untamed wildness and warrior personas. I am happy to say that Highland Justice delivers this in spades.
The author does a fantastic job transporting the reader to the wild beauty of the Highlands, where we meet the third Sinclair Brother, also fearfully known as the Horseman of Justice, who is now chief of Clan McKay. Much like his moniker, Gideon has spent his entire life maintaining fairness, order and justice for the good of the Sinclair Clan. However, he meets his match in the soft yet fiercely independent Cait McKay, who believes that beauty is found in the messy, colourful & chaotic things in life, rather than in the rigid, black and white worldview that Gideon favours. Because of a crime Cait committed, she is forced to work for Gideon to pay off her sentence, which causes sparks to fly and delcious banter to be had, and Gideon & Cait realize that perhaps there's more to each other than they first realized.
I loved seeing this couple grow from enemies to lovers - my favourite trope. It was so much fun reading about them clashing heads over their differing worldviews. They certainly knew how to challenge each other, and it made for excellent witty banter. I loved that the author made sure both characters had equally valid points in all their arguments, which made the other pause and reflect. It allowed me to appreciate where Cait & Gideon were coming from without picking sides. It also lent itself beautifully to the progression of their relationship, as both learned to respect, appreciate and value each other for their strengths, thus igniting their romance and passion for each other.
The only reason that I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because I felt that there were so many issues and external obstacles the couple had to overcome on top of the conflict they had with each other. This made it confusing for me to follow at some points, especially as the story progressed and all the subplots were coming to its head. I found that I often had to reread some areas to grasp the nuances of the varying conflicts well. I would have preferred to read about fewer conflicts, but with more page time decidated to fleshing those out for the climax of the plot. Please note that this is ofcourse my own personal preference and other readers may not see this as an issue at all.
Overall, I found Highland Justice to be an excellent read, with brilliant characters, a swoonworthy romance, exciting tension, witty banter, intelligent dialogue and thrilling action scenes. If you're a fan of historical romance with enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity and grumpyxsunshine tropes set in 16th century Scotland, then this is definitely one you do not want to miss.
March 16, 2022
This book is filled with treachery, treason, battle and more.
Cait and Gideon are meant to be together. Gideon is a great warrior who believes that the law of the land is gospel until he meets Cait. His love for her sneaks up on him.
As the new chief of Clan Mackay, Gideon Sinclair knows the importance of maintaining order at any cost. To keep the conquered clan in line, Gideon must mete out ruthless justice or risk losing their precious new peace. But from the moment he meets Cait Mackay—aye, from the moment the sweetness of her lips captures his—all of Gideon’s careful objectivity is well and thoroughly compromised.
Cait knows that kissing the brawny Highlander is a dangerous game. It was bad enough she picked his pocket to feed the children in her care, but sometimes a desperate woman must disguise her crimes any way she can. Only her act of deception has made things worse… Because one kiss with the Highland’s most brutal chief leaves her breathless and out of her depth.
Now Gideon must choose between his duty and his heart when his lovely thief is accused of treason against the king himself.
Heather McCollum has written another good book.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley. This in no way affects my opinion of this book which I read and reviewed voluntarily.
Cait and Gideon are meant to be together. Gideon is a great warrior who believes that the law of the land is gospel until he meets Cait. His love for her sneaks up on him.
As the new chief of Clan Mackay, Gideon Sinclair knows the importance of maintaining order at any cost. To keep the conquered clan in line, Gideon must mete out ruthless justice or risk losing their precious new peace. But from the moment he meets Cait Mackay—aye, from the moment the sweetness of her lips captures his—all of Gideon’s careful objectivity is well and thoroughly compromised.
Cait knows that kissing the brawny Highlander is a dangerous game. It was bad enough she picked his pocket to feed the children in her care, but sometimes a desperate woman must disguise her crimes any way she can. Only her act of deception has made things worse… Because one kiss with the Highland’s most brutal chief leaves her breathless and out of her depth.
Now Gideon must choose between his duty and his heart when his lovely thief is accused of treason against the king himself.
Heather McCollum has written another good book.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley. This in no way affects my opinion of this book which I read and reviewed voluntarily.
April 29, 2022
Highland Justice by Heather McCollum
Sons of Sinclair #3
The tale of the four horsemen of Revelation returns with the third son, Gideon Sinclair, as lead of the story. Raised as the Horseman of Justice, he has always put the law first and made judgements accordingly. When he meets Cait Mackay he begins to question some of the rules he has held so dear and wonder if perhaps his father was not 100% correct in all that he told his sons. This is the story of Gideon and Cait and how they come together and in coming together learn and grow as people and as a couple.
What I liked:
* The Sinclair brothers and their backstory’s ability to form them into the men they become
* Seeing how the brothers are doing and what has happened with the ones who have married already
* Gideon: rigid, rule bound, focused, unyielding, bound to his brothers and their purpose, prefers order, there for his family, more open to change than he realized he was
* Cait: widow, cares for several orphans, has a difficult backstory, agile, works hard to keep her “children” and neighbors safe and cared for, has much to learn as she gets to know Gideon
* The orphans and the part they played in the story
* The leaves…crunchy leaves…smiling thinking of them as I type
* Learning more about Hogmany feasts
* The gentle way Cait helped Gideon improve his relationship with the clan
* The location in time and place, the plot, and the resolution at the end
* Believing that Gideon and Cait were well suited and a believable couple
* The way the village supported Cait
* Hoping that the evil doers would be determined and dealt with
* Realizing that this era is easier to live in than the one this book was set in
* The animals
* That the supporting characters provided color and fleshed out the overall story
* That it was easy to dislike the bad guys
* The taste of history
What I didn’t like:
* Knowing how difficult it must have been to live back then
* Realizing how harsh many of the punishments were back then
* All that I was meant not to like
Did I enjoy this book? Yes
Would I read more in this series? Definitely
Thank you to NetGalley and Entangled Publishing-Amara – This is my honest review.
5 Stars
Sons of Sinclair #3
The tale of the four horsemen of Revelation returns with the third son, Gideon Sinclair, as lead of the story. Raised as the Horseman of Justice, he has always put the law first and made judgements accordingly. When he meets Cait Mackay he begins to question some of the rules he has held so dear and wonder if perhaps his father was not 100% correct in all that he told his sons. This is the story of Gideon and Cait and how they come together and in coming together learn and grow as people and as a couple.
What I liked:
* The Sinclair brothers and their backstory’s ability to form them into the men they become
* Seeing how the brothers are doing and what has happened with the ones who have married already
* Gideon: rigid, rule bound, focused, unyielding, bound to his brothers and their purpose, prefers order, there for his family, more open to change than he realized he was
* Cait: widow, cares for several orphans, has a difficult backstory, agile, works hard to keep her “children” and neighbors safe and cared for, has much to learn as she gets to know Gideon
* The orphans and the part they played in the story
* The leaves…crunchy leaves…smiling thinking of them as I type
* Learning more about Hogmany feasts
* The gentle way Cait helped Gideon improve his relationship with the clan
* The location in time and place, the plot, and the resolution at the end
* Believing that Gideon and Cait were well suited and a believable couple
* The way the village supported Cait
* Hoping that the evil doers would be determined and dealt with
* Realizing that this era is easier to live in than the one this book was set in
* The animals
* That the supporting characters provided color and fleshed out the overall story
* That it was easy to dislike the bad guys
* The taste of history
What I didn’t like:
* Knowing how difficult it must have been to live back then
* Realizing how harsh many of the punishments were back then
* All that I was meant not to like
Did I enjoy this book? Yes
Would I read more in this series? Definitely
Thank you to NetGalley and Entangled Publishing-Amara – This is my honest review.
5 Stars
April 24, 2022
The Horseman of Justice has a softer side! Cait and Gideon's love grows as she works off her stealing punishment.
What I really liked about this book that I got really hooked on it when King James came and all sorts of drama unfolded. The book really morphed from a romance into a suspense type book which was well appreciated. I has not read the previous books, but that didn't seem to matter since all of the characters really grew on me and plenty of details were given. I always love witty and brave characters (especially the female characters).
Of course the romantic scenes were plenty steamy and did not take away from the overall plot. This book was nicely balanced. The only thing I wished were a little different would have been getting to Cait's punishment a bit faster, the first few chapters were a bit on the slow side.
The next book will be interesting, the Horseman of Death finding love. Maybe Bas develops a softer side too!
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing a copy of this ARC for my honest review.
What I really liked about this book that I got really hooked on it when King James came and all sorts of drama unfolded. The book really morphed from a romance into a suspense type book which was well appreciated. I has not read the previous books, but that didn't seem to matter since all of the characters really grew on me and plenty of details were given. I always love witty and brave characters (especially the female characters).
Of course the romantic scenes were plenty steamy and did not take away from the overall plot. This book was nicely balanced. The only thing I wished were a little different would have been getting to Cait's punishment a bit faster, the first few chapters were a bit on the slow side.
The next book will be interesting, the Horseman of Death finding love. Maybe Bas develops a softer side too!
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing a copy of this ARC for my honest review.
April 10, 2022
Check out my review on my blog: http://thereadingdevil.blogspot.com/2...
Or read below!
This is the third book in the Sons of Sinclair series, but each can be read as a standalone. I read and loved Joshua's story in the second book and I was really excited for Gideon's story! I'm happy to say I was not disappointed!
As the Horseman of Justice, Gideon follows the letter of the law at all times. He doles out punishments and sentences based on what he feels is just and fair, based on both experience and copious amounts of time reading books. Cait, on the other hand, doesn't see the world in black and white. She understands the reality of all the grey areas that life holds and is unafraid to do what is necessary for those she loves regardless of how morally grey her actions may be.
I absolutely loved these two together. They complemented each other perfectly, both teaching the other something of value and importance. Gideon's view of the world becomes more flexible, and Cait begins to see herself as someone worthy of love.
There are a few arcs in the story that bring some tension and excitement, but overall it's a happy story. I like this author's writing style, and the little unique elements she adds to her stories to keep a reader turning the pages. I am quite looking forward to Bas's story - I have a feeling it may become my favorite of the series!
Or read below!
This is the third book in the Sons of Sinclair series, but each can be read as a standalone. I read and loved Joshua's story in the second book and I was really excited for Gideon's story! I'm happy to say I was not disappointed!
As the Horseman of Justice, Gideon follows the letter of the law at all times. He doles out punishments and sentences based on what he feels is just and fair, based on both experience and copious amounts of time reading books. Cait, on the other hand, doesn't see the world in black and white. She understands the reality of all the grey areas that life holds and is unafraid to do what is necessary for those she loves regardless of how morally grey her actions may be.
I absolutely loved these two together. They complemented each other perfectly, both teaching the other something of value and importance. Gideon's view of the world becomes more flexible, and Cait begins to see herself as someone worthy of love.
There are a few arcs in the story that bring some tension and excitement, but overall it's a happy story. I like this author's writing style, and the little unique elements she adds to her stories to keep a reader turning the pages. I am quite looking forward to Bas's story - I have a feeling it may become my favorite of the series!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews